138 East 36th Street

The building is a typical and handsome example of mid-1910s Manhattan apartment design: a masonry elevator house with a modest limestone base, brick shaft, and the unfussy detailing that the historic district was created to preserve. At 31 units across ten floors, the layout runs to roughly three to four apartments per floor, a density that keeps common-hallway traffic low and gives the building its intimate, owner-occupied character.

Inside, the apartments carry the pre-war features buyers come to Murray Hill for — higher ceilings than post-war stock, separate kitchens, hardwood floors, and the solid plaster-and-masonry construction that makes these buildings quiet. As an older cooperative, line-to-line variation is real: some homes have been gut-renovated to a contemporary finish while others retain original detail and offer a value-add opportunity. The total residential area of roughly 41,000 square feet across 31 homes points to comfortable, family-scaled one- and two-bedroom layouts rather than studios.

138 East 36th Street operates as a traditional, conservatively managed cooperative. The building offers part-time door attendance backed by a resident superintendent who lives on site — the staffing model that keeps monthly costs reasonable while preserving security and service. Shared facilities include a central laundry room, private storage, a bike room, and a planted interior courtyard that gives rear-facing apartments light, air, and quiet.

The building is pet-friendly, a meaningful differentiator in the pre-war co-op market. As with most cooperatives of this vintage, the board reviews purchaser applications and conducts an interview, financing is permitted within a stated cap, and subletting is allowed under board-defined terms after an initial owner-occupancy period. Buyers should plan for a standard co-op board package and the customary debt-to-income and post-closing-liquidity expectations of a stable Murray Hill building.

Recent sales

Recent transfers at this building, curated by The Roebling Team research desk. Apartment-level facts are independently verified before publishing; sale prices reflect the recorded transfer amount at the NYC Department of Finance.

Market read. Most recent trades (2026) cleared a median $796/sf across 1 sale. Median listing discount 3.7% from the last ask — a recurring negotiation gap worth pricing into any offer or listing strategy.

Sales sourced from NYC Department of Finance recorded transfers (BBL 1-00891-0062) and verified listing data. Apartment-level facts (line, condition, asking-price context) curated and cross-verified by The Roebling Team research desk. Not all transactions cross-verify with ACRIS records — sponsor and LLC purchases sometimes record at stipulated values rather than market price; square footage on co-ops is not officially recorded, figures shown are approximate.

This is a pre-war cooperative, so the purchase clears through a board: expect a full financial package, an interview, and a financing cap on the percentage of the price you may borrow. Underwrite the all-in monthly carry — maintenance plus financing — rather than price alone, and read the building's financials for reserve health and any planned capital work, which matters for any masonry building approaching and passing the century mark. Confirm the current pet policy and sublet terms against your own plans early.

The upside is specific: a true pre-war home inside a protected historic district, at a price point well below the Park and Fifth Avenue co-ops, with Grand Central and multiple subway lines minutes away. For owner-occupants who want the architecture and the address without the trophy-building premium, the value case here is strong.

Pricing a sale here is a comparable-driven exercise: with only 31 units and light turnover, the relevant set is recent closings in the building and in the immediate Murray Hill pre-war cooperative cohort. The features that move buyers are the historic-district address, the pet policy, renovation quality, light and exposure, and the manageable maintenance.

Presentation matters in a building of this kind. A renovated, well-staged apartment that photographs to its pre-war strengths — ceiling height, proportion, light — consistently outperforms an unrenovated comparable, and the spread between the two is where the right marketing earns its keep. We price to the building's real ceiling rather than the broad neighborhood average, and we prepare the board package so a qualified buyer clears review without friction.

If you're considering 138 East 36th Street, also look at these Murray Hill and Midtown East pre-war and post-war cooperatives:

• 160 East 38th Street — Murray Hill cooperative a few blocks north
• 144 East 36th Street — pre-war cooperative on the same block
• 20 East 35th Street — Murray Hill pre-war peer
• 225 East 34th Street — full-service East Side cooperative nearby