Manhattan condos $1,629/sf ▴2%Manhattan co-ops $283K/room ▴5%Central Park perimeterPark Ave $478K/room ▴19%CPW $350K/room ▴5%Fifth Ave $501K/room ▴19%Billionaires' Row $4,272/sf ▴24%West Village $2,411/sf ▴6%
Full index →
646.939.7375·
★92 Google reviews
Buildings·Gramercy·The Penny Lane·Sold prices

205 East 24th StreetRecorded sales & closing prices

205 East 24th Street, New York, NY 10010

201 recorded transfers, 2003–2026. Sortable and searchable below.

Studio
$430K
median of 5 recent · '23–'26
1BR
$550K
median of 16 recent · '23–'26
2BR
$593K
median of 2 recent · '25–'26
Recent range
$225K – $935K
all types, last 4 yrs
Listing discount
3.8%
median, from last ask
Monthly carry/sf
$2.31
≈ $2,311/mo · last 12 mo
Recorded transfers
201
2003–2026 on record

Not enough recent activity to price (shown for completeness, not quoted): 3BR — last traded 2017; 4BR+ — last traded 2023.

The complete recorded-sale history for The Penny Lane, compiled from NYC Department of Finance transfer records and verified listing data, then enriched apartment-by-apartment by The Roebling Team research desk. Priced by apartment type — the honest unit for a co-op, where square footage isn’t officially recorded.

Latest closings

2026-07 · 2BR
715  $500,000
2026-07 · 1BR
603  $625,000
2026-06
421  $712,000
2026-02 · 1BR
602  $750,000
2026-01 · Studio
201  $435,000
2025-10 · 1BR
108  $455,000

The 1BR trajectory

Every recorded 1BR. The building trades thinly year to year, so the story is the long arc, not any single year: 1BRs have moved from roughly $577K in the mid-2000s to about $550K today.

Each dot is one recorded sale, by close date and price; the line is the median for each year. Click any dot to jump straight to that sale below.

$200K$550K$900K'04'15'26603 · $625,000 · '26602 · $750,000 · '26108 · $455,000 · '25615 · $225,000 · '25104 · $405,000 · '25220 · $520,000 · '25526 · $590,000 · '24120 · $650,000 · '24111 · $440,000 · '24507 · $575,000 · '24607 · $830,000 · '24110 · $499,000 · '24503 · $450,000 · '23626 · $780,000 · '23601 · $830,000 · '23220 · $525,000 · '23614 · $480,000 · '22306 · $610,000 · '22127 · $830,000 · '21212 · $605,000 · '21505 · $585,000 · '21606 · $760,000 · '21510 · $595,000 · '21123 · $450,000 · '21116 · $680,000 · '20821 · $713,750 · '20608 · $800,000 · '20221 · $790,000 · '19524 · $735,000 · '19502 · $680,000 · '19212 · $535,000 · '18821 · $710,000 · '18307 · $775,000 · '17506 · $607,000 · '17608 · $815,000 · '15101 · $650,000 · '15123 · $455,000 · '15125 · $497,907 · '15125 · $497,908 · '15222 · $410,670 · '14511 · $540,000 · '14526 · $725,000 · '14524 · $715,000 · '14309 · $598,000 · '14610 · $635,000 · '14515 · $580,000 · '14114 · $530,000 · '14602 · $645,000 · '14308 · $582,000 · '13821 · $590,000 · '13306 · $525,000 · '13509 · $625,000 · '12605 · $620,000 · '12821 · $524,500 · '12212 · $385,320 · '12606 · $526,250 · '12619 · $423,345 · '11623 · $423,852 · '11620 · $430,950 · '11415 · $290,436 · '11415 · $290,435 · '11302 · $522,500 · '11123 · $302,752 · '11221 · $550,000 · '11526 · $592,000 · '11306 · $515,000 · '10308 · $580,000 · '10305 · $525,000 · '10510 · $560,000 · '08608 · $815,000 · '08101 · $560,000 · '08609 · $825,000 · '08427 · $800,000 · '07506 · $590,000 · '07524 · $700,000 · '07508 · $590,000 · '07302 · $550,000 · '07307 · $562,000 · '06526 · $635,000 · '06311 · $455,000 · '06609 · $568,000 · '05610 · $585,000 · '05308 · $585,000 · '05510 · $446,500 · '05605 · $460,000 · '04308 · $460,000 · '04

Lines that traded more than once

The building’s appreciation arc, apartment by apartment — recorded prices, exact.

412A+33%
$295,000 2004 → $315,000 2010 → $392,500 2015
612A+4%
$370,000 2005 → $385,000 2012

Every recorded sale

Sort any column; filter by unit or keyword. Prices are the recorded transfer amount at the NYC Department of Finance.

201 recorded sales
Apartment
Jul 7, 20267152 BR · 1 BA · 4 rm$500,000-3.8%
Jul 6, 20266031 BR · 1 BA · 3 rm$625,000-3.8%
Jun 25, 2026421$712,000—
Feb 25, 20266021 BR · 1 BA · 3 rm$750,000+0.0%
Jan 16, 2026201Studio · 1 BA · 2.5 rm$435,000-3.3%
Oct 28, 20251081 BR · 1 BA · 4 rm$455,000-9.0%
Oct 22, 20256151 BR · 1 BA$225,000—
Aug 18, 20251041 BR · 1 BA · 3 rm$405,000+8.0%
Aug 12, 202530809$1,099,000—
Aug 12, 2025823Studio · 1 BA · 2 rm$393,000-9.7%
May 8, 20252201 BR · 1 BA · 3 rm$520,000-3.5%
Jan 24, 20251142 BR · 1.5 BA · 4 rm$685,000-2.0%
Dec 3, 20245261 BR · 1 BA · 3 rm$590,000-0.8%
Sep 17, 20241201 BR · 1 BA · 4 rm$650,000-23.5%
Aug 23, 20242011 BA · 2 rm$435,000+0.0%
Jul 2, 20241111 BR · 1 BA · 3 rm$440,000-2.2%
May 28, 20243051 BRnon-market transfer (excluded from $/sf & trends)$185,000—
May 23, 2024416Studio · 1 BA · 2 rm$417,000+4.5%
Apr 23, 20245071 BR · 1 BA · 3 rm$575,000-23.3%
Feb 21, 20246071 BR · 1 BA · 3 rm$830,000-7.7%
Jan 30, 20241101 BR · 1 BA · 4 rm$499,000-5.0%
Jan 8, 2024616Studio · 1 BA · 3 rm$550,000+0.0%
Oct 23, 20235031 BR · 1 BA · 3 rm$450,000-9.8%
Aug 25, 20231154 BR · 2 BA · 6 rm$935,000-6.4%
Aug 23, 2023112AStudio · 1 BA · 3 rm$430,000-4.4%
Jun 20, 20238231 BA · 2 rm$325,000-11.9%
Apr 4, 20236261 BR · 1 BA · 3 rm$780,000-2.4%
Mar 17, 20236011 BR · 1 BA · 3 rm$830,000+1.8%
Jan 20, 20232201 BR · 1 BA · 3 rm$525,000-14.6%
Dec 29, 20226141 BR · 1 BA · 3 rm$480,000-3.8%
Dec 1, 2022316Studio · 1 BA · 2 rm$415,000-2.4%
Oct 3, 20223061 BR · 1 BA · 3 rm$610,000+1.8%
Sep 1, 2022PH3 BR · 3 BA · 7 rm$3,114,603+13.3%
Sep 1, 2022PH3 BR · 3 BA · 7 rm$3,114,604+13.3%
Aug 1, 2022521$680,000—
Jul 25, 2022204Studio · 1 BA · 2.5 rm$415,000+1.2%
May 11, 2022822Studio · 1 BA · 1 rm$410,000-2.4%
Nov 9, 2021723Studio · 1 BA · 2 rm$415,000-2.4%
Oct 27, 20211271 BR · 4 rm$830,000-5.0%
Sep 8, 2021214Studio · 1 BA · 2 rm$540,000-1.8%
Jul 22, 2021224Studio · 1 BA · 2 rm$370,000-12.9%
Jun 30, 20212121 BR · 1 BA · 3 rm$605,000-11.7%
Jun 17, 20215051 BR · 1 BA · 1 rm$585,000-1.7%
May 20, 20216061 BR · 1 BA · 3 rm$760,000-2.4%
Apr 22, 2021401$410,762—
Apr 13, 20215101 BR · 1 BA · 3 rm$595,000-4.8%
Mar 3, 2021203Studio · 1 BA · 2.5 rm$438,500-11.4%
Mar 3, 20211231 BR · 1 BA · 3 rm$450,000-9.1%
Feb 16, 2021209Studio · 1 BA · 2 rm$440,000-11.1%
Jan 28, 2021409Studio · 1 BA · 2 rm$525,500-4.5%
Dec 16, 20201161 BR · 1 BA · 4 rm$680,000-9.3%
Dec 14, 20208211 BR · 1 BA · 3 rm$713,750-9.1%
Nov 5, 2020426$410,762—
Oct 14, 2020405Studio · 1 BA · 2 rm$395,000+0.0%
May 28, 20206081 BR$800,000—
Dec 20, 2019318Studio · 1 BA · 2 rm$400,338+8.5%
Aug 28, 20192211 BR · 1.5 BA · 3.5 rm$790,000-4.7%
Jul 17, 2019718Studio · 1 BA · 2 rm$386,000-3.3%
Jun 6, 20195241 BR · 1 BA · 3 rm$735,000+1.4%
May 7, 20195021 BR · 1 BA · 3 rm$680,000+0.0%
Mar 26, 2019403Studio · 1 BA · 2 rm$530,000+0.0%
Feb 28, 2019402$375,000—
Nov 30, 2018304Studio · 2 rm$475,566-4.7%
Jul 11, 20182121 BR · 1 BA · 3 rm$535,000+1.9%
Jun 27, 2018312Studio · 2 rm$430,000-4.2%
Apr 24, 20188211 BR · 1 BA · 4 rm$710,000+2.2%
Feb 14, 2018719Studio$395,000—
Oct 13, 2017419Studio · 2 rm$430,020+2.4%
Oct 13, 2017419Studio · 2 rm$430,021+2.4%
Oct 5, 2017218Studio · 1.5 BA · 2 rm$686,000+14.3%
Sep 20, 2017208Studio · 2 rm$445,000-0.9%
Jun 30, 20173071 BR · 3 rm$775,000-0.5%
Jun 7, 2017103Studio · 1 BA · 2 rm$642,000-2.6%
Jun 5, 20176243 BR · 2.5 BA · 5 rm$1,810,000+3.4%
May 24, 20172262273 BR · 6 rm$1,698,000-1.6%
Apr 27, 2017514Studio · 2 rm$430,000+0.2%
Apr 26, 20173253 BR · 5 rm$1,835,000+4.9%
Feb 9, 2017712Studio · 2 rm$425,000-1.2%
Feb 7, 2017424Studio · 2 rm$417,500-9.0%
Jan 12, 20175061 BR · 1 BA · 4 rm$607,000+0.0%
Dec 29, 20166042 BR$800,000—
Sep 15, 2016523Studio · 2 rm$420,000-2.3%
Aug 9, 2016214Studio · 1 BA · 3 rm$489,000+0.0%
Apr 26, 2016614Studio · 1 BA · 2.5 rm$485,000-2.0%
Nov 4, 20156081 BR · 3 rm$815,000+2.0%
Oct 5, 20151011 BR · 3 rm$650,000-6.5%
Jun 26, 2015412AStudio · 2 rm$392,500-4.3%
Jun 4, 20151231 BR · 3 rm$455,000-1.1%
Apr 2, 20151251 BR · 3 rm$497,907+10.6%
Apr 2, 20151251 BR · 3 rm$497,908+10.6%
Dec 23, 20141182 BR · 5 rm$970,000-13.8%
Nov 25, 20142221 BR · 3 rm$410,670+0.2%
Oct 17, 2014418Studio · 2 rm$379,000-4.1%
Aug 20, 20145111 BR · 1 BA · 3 rm$540,000-13.6%
Aug 6, 20145261 BR · 3 rm$725,000+0.0%
Aug 4, 20145241 BR · 3 rm$715,000-4.5%
Jul 2, 2014316Studio · 2 rm$415,000-4.6%
Jul 1, 20143091 BR · 3 rm$598,000-5.8%
Jun 18, 20146101 BR · 3 rm$635,000-2.2%
Jun 4, 2014515Co-op Sponsor Transfer1 BR · 3 rm$580,000-3.2%
May 7, 20141141 BR$530,000—
Feb 27, 20146042 BR · 1 BA$680,000—
Feb 18, 20146021 BR · 3 rm$645,000+0.0%
Feb 3, 2014319Studio · 1 BA · 2 rm$378,500-2.7%
Oct 16, 20133253 BR · 6 rm$1,360,000-9.0%
Jul 10, 2013814Studio · 2 rm$437,000+0.5%
Jun 10, 2013712Studio · 2.5 rm$335,000-4.0%
Jun 10, 20133081 BR · 1 BA · 4 rm$582,000-2.8%
May 16, 20138211 BR · 3 rm$590,000+1.9%
May 3, 2013218Co-op Sponsor Transfer1 BR · 3 rmnon-market transfer (excluded from $/sf & trends)$370,000—
May 1, 20133061 BR · 3 rm$525,000+0.0%
Apr 4, 20138202 rm$382,500-12.9%
Jan 24, 2013527$425,880—
Sep 28, 2012102Studio · 2 rm$385,000-2.5%
Sep 26, 2012509Co-op Sponsor Transfer1 BR · 3 rm$625,000-3.7%
Aug 28, 20126051 BR · 3 rm$620,000-0.8%
Jul 23, 20121214 BR · 2 BA$1,280,000—
Jun 13, 20128211 BR$524,500—
May 31, 2012212Co-op Sponsor Transfer1 BR · 3 rm$385,320-1.2%
May 8, 20126061 BR · 1 BA$526,250—
Apr 5, 2012525$495,000—
Apr 2, 2012612AStudio · 2 rm$385,000-3.3%
Dec 13, 20116191 BR · 3 rm$423,345-0.4%
Dec 8, 2011409Co-op Sponsor TransferStudio · 2 rm$334,000-3.2%
Nov 21, 20116231 BR · 3 rm$423,852-0.3%
Oct 13, 20116201 BR · 3 rm$430,950-9.3%
Jul 27, 20114151 BR · 1 BA$290,436—
Jul 27, 20114151 BR · 1 BA$290,435—
Jul 14, 2011823Studio$305,000—
Jul 14, 20113021 BR · 3 rm$522,500-4.8%
Jun 28, 20111162 BR · 5 rm$569,000-6.7%
Jun 20, 20111231 BR$302,752—
Jun 9, 2011226$372,500—
Jan 19, 20112211 BR · 4 rm$550,000+0.2%
Jan 3, 20115261 BR · 3 rm$592,000-8.8%
Nov 9, 2010614Studio$355,000—
Oct 28, 2010617Studio · 2 rm$438,045-14.9%
Sep 30, 2010719Studio · 2 rm$360,000-5.0%
Jul 14, 2010522Co-op Sponsor TransferStudio · 2 rm$320,000-5.9%
Jun 30, 2010412AStudio · 2 rm$315,000-3.7%
Jun 7, 20101272 BR · 4 rm$656,771-6.2%
May 27, 20103061 BR · 3 rm$515,000-1.9%
May 20, 20103081 BR · 4 rm$580,000-3.2%
Feb 5, 20103051 BR · 3 rm$525,000-8.7%
Oct 7, 2009817Studio · 2 rm$400,000-5.9%
Jul 2, 2009224Co-op Sponsor TransferStudio · 2 rm$350,000-6.7%
Mar 31, 2009504Co-op Sponsor TransferStudio · 2 rm$365,000-8.5%
Feb 2, 2009207Studio · 2 rm$330,000-10.6%
Nov 13, 2008425Studio · 2 rm$375,000-3.6%
Jul 29, 20082273 BR · 6 rm$706,000-5.9%
Jul 23, 20085101 BR · 3 rm$560,000-1.6%
Jul 22, 20086081 BR$815,000—
Jun 9, 20081011 BR$560,000—
May 20, 20081214 BR · 2 BA$1,150,000—
May 19, 2008424Studio · 2 rm$378,000-2.8%
May 15, 20086091 BR · 3 rm$825,000+0.0%
Dec 11, 2007427Co-op Sponsor Transfer1 BR · 3 rm$800,000+0.0%
Nov 14, 2007214Studio · 3 rm$524,700+0.0%
Nov 7, 20075061 BR · 4 rm$590,000-1.5%
Sep 12, 2007618Co-op Sponsor TransferStudio · 2 rm$390,000-7.1%
Aug 27, 2007518Studio · 2 rm$355,000+0.0%
Jun 28, 20075241 BR · 3 rm$700,000+1.4%
Jun 20, 2007314Studio · 2 rm$330,000-2.7%
Jun 14, 2007614Studio$410,000—
May 31, 2007319Co-op Sponsor TransferStudio · 2 rm$323,000-6.4%
May 23, 20071182 BR · 5 rm$755,000+8.0%
May 3, 20075081 BR · 3 rm$590,000-1.5%
Feb 21, 2007302Co-op Sponsor Transfer1 BR · 3 rm$550,000-4.3%
Oct 30, 2006103Studio · 2 rm$417,500-1.8%
Sep 13, 20063071 BR · 3 rm$562,000-10.1%
Jun 28, 20065261 BR · 3 rm$635,000-5.1%
May 4, 20063111 BR · 3 rm$455,000-15.6%
May 4, 2006712AStudio · 2 rm$295,000-1.6%
Feb 2, 2006723Studio · 1 rm$365,000-6.4%
Nov 16, 20056091 BR$568,000—
Nov 15, 2005817Studio · 2 rm$425,000-10.5%
Nov 7, 2005425Co-op Sponsor TransferStudio · 2 rm$340,000-2.9%
Oct 11, 2005216217Co-op Sponsor Transfer2 BR · 4 rm$699,000+0.0%
Oct 5, 2005610Co-op Sponsor Transfer1 BR · 3 rm$585,000-6.4%
Sep 28, 2005405Studio · 2 rm$310,000-4.6%
Sep 12, 2005216$685,000—
Aug 23, 2005226$405,000—
Aug 17, 2005314Studio$252,000—
Jul 25, 20053081 BR$585,000—
Jun 29, 20055101 BR$446,500—
Jun 28, 2005814Studio$216,200—
Jun 23, 2005102Studio$308,000—
May 12, 2005625$465,000—
May 11, 2005614Studio · 2 rm$383,000+0.8%
Apr 19, 2005424Studio · 2 rm$299,000+0.0%
Apr 7, 2005612AStudio · 1 BA · 2 rm$370,000-7.3%
Feb 2, 2005315$380,000—
Dec 10, 20046051 BR$460,000—
Sep 8, 2004412AStudio$295,000—
Jul 13, 2004518Studio$240,000—
Jul 6, 20043081 BR$460,000—
Jun 10, 2004719Studio · 2 rm$259,000+0.0%
May 27, 2004720Co-op Sponsor TransferStudio · 2 rm$310,000-4.6%
Feb 24, 2004403Studio · 2 rm$279,000+0.0%
Sep 22, 2003201Co-op Sponsor TransferStudio · 2 rm$265,000+0.0%
Sep 17, 20031182 BR · 5 rm$449,000+0.0%

Sales sourced from NYC Department of Finance recorded transfers (BBL 1-00905-0006) and verified listing data. Co-op apartments are priced by unit type (bedroom count) rather than per square foot — square footage isn’t officially recorded for co-ops, and room counts carry some agent-entry inconsistency, so bedroom type is the reliable spine. Non-arms-length transfers and storage/parking are excluded; line and floor premiums are time-controlled to today’s pricing. Where transaction volume is too thin to support a figure, none is shown.

Buying or selling at The Penny Lane?

Put this data to work.

Buying here

Know what’s fair before you offer — we’ll show you where each line trades, the building’s discount-to-ask pattern, and where the value sits right now.

Selling here

Price to the building’s real trajectory, not a guess — we’ll position your line against its true comps to maximize the outcome.

Schedule a consultation →
Corey Cohen · The Roebling Team at Compass
646.939.7375 · c.cohen@compass.com