Manhattan condos · below 96th $1,623/sf ▴3%Manhattan co-ops · below 96th $272K/room ▴4%Central Park perimeterPark Ave $452K/room ▴3%CPW $484K/roomFifth Ave $550K/roomBillionaires' Row $3,350/sfFiDi $1,215/sf ▾6%
Full index →

Back to The Penny Lane building profile

205 East 24th StreetRecorded sales & closing prices

205 East 24th Street, New York, NY 10010

197 recorded transfers, 2003–2026. Sortable and searchable below.

Own an apartment at The Penny Lane?
Enter your apartment to see its recorded sale history and today’s estimate.
Studio
$430K
median of 5 recent · '23–'26
1BR
$575K
median of 15 recent · '23–'26
2BR
$593K
median of 2 recent · '25–'26
Recent range
$393K – $935K
all types, last 4 yrs
Listing discount
3.8%
median, from last ask
Monthly carry/sf
$2.31
≈ $1,964/mo · last 2 yrs
Recorded transfers
197
2003–2026 on record

Not enough recent activity to price (shown for completeness, not quoted): 3BR — last traded 2017; 4BR+ — last traded 2023.

The complete recorded-sale history for The Penny Lane, compiled from NYC Department of Finance transfer records, with apartment-by-apartment detail from The Roebling Research Library. Priced by apartment type — the honest unit for a co-op, where square footage isn’t officially recorded.

Latest closings

2026-07 · 2BR
715  $500,000
2026-07 · 1BR
603  $625,000
2026-06
421  $712,000
2026-02 · 1BR
602  $750,000
2026-01 · Studio
201  $435,000
2025-10 · 1BR
108  $455,000

The 1BR trajectory

Every recorded 1BR. The building trades thinly year to year, so the story is the long arc, not any single year: 1BRs traded at roughly $590K in 2006–09 and about $575K in recent sales.

Each dot is one recorded sale, by close date and price; the line is the median for each year. Click any dot to jump straight to that sale below.

$350K$625K$900K'06'16'26603 · $625,000 · '26602 · $750,000 · '26108 · $455,000 · '25104 · $405,000 · '25220 · $520,000 · '25526 · $590,000 · '24120 · $650,000 · '24111 · $440,000 · '24507 · $575,000 · '24607 · $830,000 · '24110 · $499,000 · '24503 · $450,000 · '23626 · $780,000 · '23601 · $830,000 · '23220 · $525,000 · '23614 · $480,000 · '22306 · $610,000 · '22127 · $830,000 · '21212 · $605,000 · '21505 · $585,000 · '21606 · $760,000 · '21510 · $595,000 · '21123 · $450,000 · '21116 · $680,000 · '20821 · $713,750 · '20221 · $790,000 · '19524 · $735,000 · '19502 · $680,000 · '19212 · $535,000 · '18821 · $710,000 · '18307 · $775,000 · '17506 · $607,000 · '17608 · $815,000 · '15101 · $650,000 · '15123 · $455,000 · '15125 · $497,907 · '15222 · $410,670 · '14511 · $540,000 · '14526 · $725,000 · '14524 · $715,000 · '14309 · $598,000 · '14610 · $635,000 · '14602 · $645,000 · '14308 · $582,000 · '13821 · $590,000 · '13306 · $525,000 · '13605 · $620,000 · '12619 · $423,345 · '11623 · $423,852 · '11620 · $430,950 · '11302 · $522,500 · '11221 · $550,000 · '11526 · $592,000 · '11306 · $515,000 · '10308 · $580,000 · '10305 · $525,000 · '10510 · $560,000 · '08609 · $825,000 · '08506 · $590,000 · '07524 · $700,000 · '07508 · $590,000 · '07307 · $562,000 · '06526 · $635,000 · '06311 · $455,000 · '06

The Studio trajectory

Every recorded Studio. The building trades thinly year to year, so the story is the long arc, not any single year: Studios traded at roughly $355K in 2004–07 and about $430K in recent sales.

Each dot is one recorded sale, by close date and price; the line is the median for each year. Click any dot to jump straight to that sale below.

$200K$475K$750K'04'15'26201 · $435,000 · '26823 · $393,000 · '25416 · $417,000 · '24616 · $550,000 · '24112A · $430,000 · '23316 · $415,000 · '22204 · $415,000 · '22822 · $410,000 · '22723 · $415,000 · '21214 · $540,000 · '21224 · $370,000 · '21203 · $438,500 · '21209 · $440,000 · '21409 · $525,500 · '21405 · $395,000 · '20318 · $400,338 · '19718 · $386,000 · '19403 · $530,000 · '19304 · $475,566 · '18312 · $430,000 · '18419 · $430,020 · '17218 · $686,000 · '17208 · $445,000 · '17103 · $642,000 · '17514 · $430,000 · '17712 · $425,000 · '17424 · $417,500 · '17523 · $420,000 · '16214 · $489,000 · '16614 · $485,000 · '16412A · $392,500 · '15418 · $379,000 · '14316 · $415,000 · '14319 · $378,500 · '14814 · $437,000 · '13712 · $335,000 · '13102 · $385,000 · '12612A · $385,000 · '12617 · $438,045 · '10719 · $360,000 · '10412A · $315,000 · '10817 · $400,000 · '09207 · $330,000 · '09425 · $375,000 · '08424 · $378,000 · '08214 · $524,700 · '07518 · $355,000 · '07314 · $330,000 · '07103 · $417,500 · '06712A · $295,000 · '06723 · $365,000 · '06817 · $425,000 · '05405 · $310,000 · '05614 · $383,000 · '05424 · $299,000 · '05612A · $370,000 · '05719 · $259,000 · '04403 · $279,000 · '04

Lines that traded more than once

The building’s appreciation arc, apartment by apartment — recorded prices, exact.

412A+25%
$315,000 2010 → $392,500 2015
612A+4%
$370,000 2005 → $385,000 2012

Every recorded sale

Sort any column; filter by unit or keyword. Prices are the recorded transfer amount at the NYC Department of Finance.

197 recorded sales
Apartment
Jul 7, 20267152 BR · 1 BA · 4 rm$500,000-3.8%
Jul 6, 20266031 BR · 1 BA · 3 rm$625,000-3.8%
Jun 25, 2026421$712,000—
Feb 25, 20266021 BR · 1 BA · 3 rm$750,000+0.0%
Jan 16, 2026201Studio · 1 BA · 2.5 rm$435,000-3.3%
Oct 28, 20251081 BR · 1 BA · 4 rm$455,000-9.0%
Oct 22, 20256151 BR · 1 BAnon-market transfer (excluded from $/sf & trends)$225,000—
Aug 18, 20251041 BR · 1 BA · 3 rm$405,000+8.0%
Aug 12, 2025823Studio · 1 BA · 2 rm$393,000-9.7%
Aug 12, 202530809$1,099,000—
May 8, 20252201 BR · 1 BA · 3 rm$520,000-3.5%
Jan 24, 20251142 BR · 1.5 BA · 4 rm$685,000-2.0%
Dec 3, 20245261 BR · 1 BA · 3 rm$590,000-0.8%
Sep 17, 20241201 BR · 1 BA · 4 rm$650,000-23.5%
Aug 23, 20242011 BA · 2 rm$435,000+0.0%
Jul 2, 20241111 BR · 1 BA · 3 rm$440,000-2.2%
May 28, 20243051 BRnon-market transfer (excluded from $/sf & trends)$185,000—
May 23, 2024416Studio · 1 BA · 2 rm$417,000+4.5%
Apr 23, 20245071 BR · 1 BA · 3 rm$575,000-23.3%
Feb 21, 20246071 BR · 1 BA · 3 rm$830,000-7.7%
Jan 30, 20241101 BR · 1 BA · 4 rm$499,000-5.0%
Jan 8, 2024616Studio · 1 BA · 3 rm$550,000+0.0%
Oct 23, 20235031 BR · 1 BA · 3 rm$450,000-9.8%
Aug 25, 20231154 BR · 2 BA · 6 rm$935,000-6.4%
Aug 23, 2023112AStudio · 1 BA · 3 rm$430,000-4.4%
Jun 20, 20238231 BA · 2 rm$325,000-11.9%
Apr 4, 20236261 BR · 1 BA · 3 rm$780,000-2.4%
Mar 17, 20236011 BR · 1 BA · 3 rm$830,000+1.8%
Jan 20, 20232201 BR · 1 BA · 3 rm$525,000-14.6%
Dec 29, 20226141 BR · 1 BA · 3 rm$480,000-3.8%
Dec 1, 2022316Studio · 1 BA · 2 rm$415,000-2.4%
Oct 3, 20223061 BR · 1 BA · 3 rm$610,000+1.8%
Sep 1, 2022PH3 BR · 3 BA · 7 rm$3,114,603+13.3%
Aug 1, 2022521$680,000—
Jul 25, 2022204Studio · 1 BA · 2.5 rm$415,000+1.2%
May 11, 2022822Studio · 1 BA · 1 rm$410,000-2.4%
Nov 9, 2021723Studio · 1 BA · 2 rm$415,000-2.4%
Oct 27, 20211271 BR · 4 rm$830,000-5.0%
Sep 8, 2021214Studio · 1 BA · 2 rm$540,000-1.8%
Jul 22, 2021224Studio · 1 BA · 2 rm$370,000-12.9%
Jun 30, 20212121 BR · 1 BA · 3 rm$605,000-11.7%
Jun 17, 20215051 BR · 1 BA · 1 rm$585,000-1.7%
May 20, 20216061 BR · 1 BA · 3 rm$760,000-2.4%
Apr 22, 2021401$410,762—
Apr 13, 20215101 BR · 1 BA · 3 rm$595,000-4.8%
Mar 3, 2021203Studio · 1 BA · 2.5 rm$438,500-11.4%
Mar 3, 20211231 BR · 1 BA · 3 rm$450,000-9.1%
Feb 16, 2021209Studio · 1 BA · 2 rm$440,000-11.1%
Jan 28, 2021409Studio · 1 BA · 2 rm$525,500-4.5%
Dec 16, 20201161 BR · 1 BA · 4 rm$680,000-9.3%
Dec 14, 20208211 BR · 1 BA · 3 rm$713,750-9.1%
Nov 5, 2020426$410,762—
Oct 14, 2020405Studio · 1 BA · 2 rm$395,000+0.0%
May 28, 20206081 BRoutside the market statistics (eligibility screen)$800,000—
Dec 20, 2019318Studio · 1 BA · 2 rm$400,338+8.5%
Aug 28, 20192211 BR · 1.5 BA · 3.5 rm$790,000-4.7%
Jul 17, 2019718Studio · 1 BA · 2 rm$386,000-3.3%
Jun 6, 20195241 BR · 1 BA · 3 rm$735,000+1.4%
May 7, 20195021 BR · 1 BA · 3 rm$680,000+0.0%
Mar 26, 2019403Studio · 1 BA · 2 rm$530,000+0.0%
Feb 28, 2019402$375,000—
Nov 30, 2018304Studio · 2 rm$475,566-4.7%
Jul 11, 20182121 BR · 1 BA · 3 rm$535,000+1.9%
Jun 27, 2018312Studio · 2 rm$430,000-4.2%
Apr 24, 20188211 BR · 1 BA · 4 rm$710,000+2.2%
Feb 14, 2018719Studiooutside the market statistics (eligibility screen)$395,000—
Oct 13, 2017419Studio · 2 rm$430,020+2.4%
Oct 5, 2017218Studio · 1.5 BA · 2 rm$686,000+14.3%
Sep 20, 2017208Studio · 2 rm$445,000-0.9%
Jun 30, 20173071 BR · 3 rm$775,000-0.5%
Jun 7, 2017103Studio · 1 BA · 2 rm$642,000-2.6%
Jun 5, 20176243 BR · 2.5 BA · 5 rm$1,810,000+3.4%
May 24, 20172262273 BR · 6 rm$1,698,000-1.6%
Apr 27, 2017514Studio · 2 rm$430,000+0.2%
Apr 26, 20173253 BR · 5 rm$1,835,000+4.9%
Feb 9, 2017712Studio · 2 rm$425,000-1.2%
Feb 7, 2017424Studio · 2 rm$417,500-9.0%
Jan 12, 20175061 BR · 1 BA · 4 rm$607,000+0.0%
Dec 29, 20166042 BRoutside the market statistics (eligibility screen)$800,000—
Sep 15, 2016523Studio · 2 rm$420,000-2.3%
Aug 9, 2016214Studio · 1 BA · 3 rm$489,000+0.0%
Apr 26, 2016614Studio · 1 BA · 2.5 rm$485,000-2.0%
Nov 4, 20156081 BR · 3 rm$815,000+2.0%
Oct 5, 20151011 BR · 3 rm$650,000-6.5%
Jun 26, 2015412AStudio · 2 rm$392,500-4.3%
Jun 4, 20151231 BR · 3 rm$455,000-1.1%
Apr 2, 20151251 BR · 3 rm$497,907+10.6%
Dec 23, 20141182 BR · 5 rm$970,000-13.8%
Nov 25, 20142221 BR · 3 rm$410,670+0.2%
Oct 17, 2014418Studio · 2 rm$379,000-4.1%
Aug 20, 20145111 BR · 1 BA · 3 rm$540,000-13.6%
Aug 6, 20145261 BR · 3 rm$725,000+0.0%
Aug 4, 20145241 BR · 3 rm$715,000-4.5%
Jul 2, 2014316Studio · 2 rm$415,000-4.6%
Jul 1, 20143091 BR · 3 rm$598,000-5.8%
Jun 18, 20146101 BR · 3 rm$635,000-2.2%
Jun 4, 2014515Co-op Sponsor Transfer1 BR · 3 rmoutside the market statistics (eligibility screen)$580,000-3.2%
May 7, 20141141 BRoutside the market statistics (eligibility screen)$530,000—
Feb 27, 20146042 BR · 1 BAoutside the market statistics (eligibility screen)$680,000—
Feb 18, 20146021 BR · 3 rm$645,000+0.0%
Feb 3, 2014319Studio · 1 BA · 2 rm$378,500-2.7%
Oct 16, 20133253 BR · 6 rm$1,360,000-9.0%
Jul 10, 2013814Studio · 2 rm$437,000+0.5%
Jun 10, 20133081 BR · 1 BA · 4 rm$582,000-2.8%
Jun 10, 2013712Studio · 2.5 rm$335,000-4.0%
May 16, 20138211 BR · 3 rm$590,000+1.9%
May 3, 2013218Co-op Sponsor Transfer1 BR · 3 rmnon-market transfer (excluded from $/sf & trends)$370,000—
May 1, 20133061 BR · 3 rm$525,000+0.0%
Apr 4, 20138202 rm$382,500-12.9%
Jan 24, 2013527$425,880—
Sep 28, 2012102Studio · 2 rm$385,000-2.5%
Sep 26, 2012509Co-op Sponsor Transfer1 BR · 3 rmoutside the market statistics (eligibility screen)$625,000-3.7%
Aug 28, 20126051 BR · 3 rm$620,000-0.8%
Jul 23, 20121214 BR · 2 BAoutside the market statistics (eligibility screen)$1,280,000—
Jun 13, 20128211 BRoutside the market statistics (eligibility screen)$524,500—
May 31, 2012212Co-op Sponsor Transfer1 BR · 3 rmoutside the market statistics (eligibility screen)$385,320-1.2%
May 8, 20126061 BR · 1 BAoutside the market statistics (eligibility screen)$526,250—
Apr 5, 2012525$495,000—
Apr 2, 2012612AStudio · 2 rm$385,000-3.3%
Dec 13, 20116191 BR · 3 rm$423,345-0.4%
Dec 8, 2011409Co-op Sponsor TransferStudio · 2 rmoutside the market statistics (eligibility screen)$334,000-3.2%
Nov 21, 20116231 BR · 3 rm$423,852-0.3%
Oct 13, 20116201 BR · 3 rm$430,950-9.3%
Jul 27, 20114151 BR · 1 BAoutside the market statistics (eligibility screen)$290,435—
Jul 14, 2011823Studiooutside the market statistics (eligibility screen)$305,000—
Jul 14, 20113021 BR · 3 rm$522,500-4.8%
Jun 28, 20111162 BR · 5 rm$569,000-6.7%
Jun 20, 20111231 BRoutside the market statistics (eligibility screen)$302,752—
Jun 9, 2011226$372,500—
Jan 19, 20112211 BR · 4 rm$550,000+0.2%
Jan 3, 20115261 BR · 3 rm$592,000-8.8%
Nov 9, 2010614Studiooutside the market statistics (eligibility screen)$355,000—
Oct 28, 2010617Studio · 2 rm$438,045-14.9%
Sep 30, 2010719Studio · 2 rm$360,000-5.0%
Jul 14, 2010522Co-op Sponsor TransferStudio · 2 rmoutside the market statistics (eligibility screen)$320,000-5.9%
Jun 30, 2010412AStudio · 2 rm$315,000-3.7%
Jun 7, 20101272 BR · 4 rm$656,771-6.2%
May 27, 20103061 BR · 3 rm$515,000-1.9%
May 20, 20103081 BR · 4 rm$580,000-3.2%
Feb 5, 20103051 BR · 3 rm$525,000-8.7%
Oct 7, 2009817Studio · 2 rm$400,000-5.9%
Jul 2, 2009224Co-op Sponsor TransferStudio · 2 rmoutside the market statistics (eligibility screen)$350,000-6.7%
Mar 31, 2009504Co-op Sponsor TransferStudio · 2 rmoutside the market statistics (eligibility screen)$365,000-8.5%
Feb 2, 2009207Studio · 2 rm$330,000-10.6%
Nov 13, 2008425Studio · 2 rm$375,000-3.6%
Jul 29, 20082273 BR · 6 rm$706,000-5.9%
Jul 23, 20085101 BR · 3 rm$560,000-1.6%
Jul 22, 20086081 BRoutside the market statistics (eligibility screen)$815,000—
Jun 9, 20081011 BRoutside the market statistics (eligibility screen)$560,000—
May 20, 20081214 BR · 2 BAoutside the market statistics (eligibility screen)$1,150,000—
May 19, 2008424Studio · 2 rm$378,000-2.8%
May 15, 20086091 BR · 3 rm$825,000+0.0%
Dec 11, 2007427Co-op Sponsor Transfer1 BR · 3 rmoutside the market statistics (eligibility screen)$800,000+0.0%
Nov 14, 2007214Studio · 3 rm$524,700+0.0%
Nov 7, 20075061 BR · 4 rm$590,000-1.5%
Sep 12, 2007618Co-op Sponsor TransferStudio · 2 rmoutside the market statistics (eligibility screen)$390,000-7.1%
Aug 27, 2007518Studio · 2 rm$355,000+0.0%
Jun 28, 20075241 BR · 3 rm$700,000+1.4%
Jun 20, 2007314Studio · 2 rm$330,000-2.7%
Jun 14, 2007614Studiooutside the market statistics (eligibility screen)$410,000—
May 31, 2007319Co-op Sponsor TransferStudio · 2 rmoutside the market statistics (eligibility screen)$323,000-6.4%
May 23, 20071182 BR · 5 rm$755,000+8.0%
May 3, 20075081 BR · 3 rm$590,000-1.5%
Feb 21, 2007302Co-op Sponsor Transfer1 BR · 3 rmoutside the market statistics (eligibility screen)$550,000-4.3%
Oct 30, 2006103Studio · 2 rm$417,500-1.8%
Sep 13, 20063071 BR · 3 rm$562,000-10.1%
Jun 28, 20065261 BR · 3 rm$635,000-5.1%
May 4, 2006712AStudio · 2 rm$295,000-1.6%
May 4, 20063111 BR · 3 rm$455,000-15.6%
Feb 2, 2006723Studio · 1 rm$365,000-6.4%
Nov 16, 20056091 BRoutside the market statistics (eligibility screen)$568,000—
Nov 15, 2005817Studio · 2 rm$425,000-10.5%
Nov 7, 2005425Co-op Sponsor TransferStudio · 2 rmoutside the market statistics (eligibility screen)$340,000-2.9%
Oct 11, 2005216217Co-op Sponsor Transfer2 BR · 4 rm$699,000+0.0%
Oct 5, 2005610Co-op Sponsor Transfer1 BR · 3 rmoutside the market statistics (eligibility screen)$585,000-6.4%
Sep 28, 2005405Studio · 2 rm$310,000-4.6%
Sep 12, 2005216$685,000—
Aug 23, 2005226$405,000—
Aug 17, 2005314Studiooutside the market statistics (eligibility screen)$252,000—
Jul 25, 20053081 BRoutside the market statistics (eligibility screen)$585,000—
Jun 29, 20055101 BRoutside the market statistics (eligibility screen)$446,500—
Jun 28, 2005814Studionon-market transfer (excluded from $/sf & trends)$216,200—
Jun 23, 2005102Studiooutside the market statistics (eligibility screen)$308,000—
May 12, 2005625$465,000—
May 11, 2005614Studio · 2 rm$383,000+0.8%
Apr 19, 2005424Studio · 2 rm$299,000+0.0%
Apr 7, 2005612AStudio · 1 BA · 2 rm$370,000-7.3%
Feb 2, 2005315$380,000—
Dec 10, 20046051 BRoutside the market statistics (eligibility screen)$460,000—
Sep 8, 2004412AStudiooutside the market statistics (eligibility screen)$295,000—
Jul 13, 2004518Studiooutside the market statistics (eligibility screen)$240,000—
Jul 6, 20043081 BRoutside the market statistics (eligibility screen)$460,000—
Jun 10, 2004719Studio · 2 rm$259,000+0.0%
May 27, 2004720Co-op Sponsor TransferStudio · 2 rmoutside the market statistics (eligibility screen)$310,000-4.6%
Feb 24, 2004403Studio · 2 rm$279,000+0.0%
Sep 22, 2003201Co-op Sponsor TransferStudio · 2 rmoutside the market statistics (eligibility screen)$265,000+0.0%
Sep 17, 20031182 BR · 5 rm$449,000+0.0%

Sales sourced from NYC Department of Finance recorded transfers (BBL 1-00905-0006) and verified listing data. Co-op apartments are priced by unit type (bedroom count) rather than per square foot — square footage isn’t officially recorded for co-ops, and room counts carry some agent-entry inconsistency, so bedroom type is the reliable spine. Non-arms-length transfers and storage/parking are excluded; line and floor premiums are time-controlled to today’s pricing. Where transaction volume is too thin to support a figure, none is shown.

Buying or selling at The Penny Lane?

Put this data to work.

Buying here

Know what’s fair before you offer — we’ll show you where each line trades, the building’s discount-to-ask pattern, and where the value sits right now.

Selling here

Price to the building’s real trajectory, not a guess — we’ll position your line against its true comps to maximize the outcome.

Schedule a consultation →
Corey Cohen · The Roebling Team at Compass
646.939.7375 · c.cohen@compass.com