646.939.7375·
★92 Google reviews
Buildings·Upper East Side·The Plymouth House·Sold prices

235 East 87th Street (The Plymouth House)Recorded sales & closing prices

235 East 87th Street, New York, NY 10128

147 recorded transfers, 2004–2026. Sortable and searchable below.

1BR
$543K
median of 4 recent · '24–'25
2BR
$866K
median of 4 recent · '23–'25
3BR
$1.13M
median of 2 recent · '25–'26
4BR+
$540K
median of 3 recent · '24–'25
Recent range
$520K – $2.69M
all types, last 4 yrs
Listing discount
2.7%
median, from last ask
Recorded transfers
147
2004–2026 on record

Not enough recent activity to price (shown for completeness, not quoted): Studio — last traded 2025.

The complete recorded-sale history for The Plymouth House, compiled from NYC Department of Finance transfer records and verified listing data, then enriched apartment-by-apartment by The Roebling Team research desk. Priced by apartment type — the honest unit for a co-op, where square footage isn’t officially recorded.

Latest closings

2026-03 · 3BR
10K  $1,115,000
2025-12 · 4BR+
9I  $540,000
2025-11 · 2BR
10B  $810,000
2025-07 · 4BR+
7E  $520,000
2025-06 · 3BR
9K  $1,140,000
2025-05 · 1BR
6H  $570,000

The line premium — where you sit sets the price

Same-2BR prices, time-controlled to today’s dollars, split by line — exposure, light, and layout vary stack to stack within a building.

Bar = today’s 2BR price for that line; right column = premium vs. an average 2BR.

Line C 4 sales
$1,284,301
+48%
Line L 4 sales
$847,066
-2%
Line D 5 sales
$812,313
-6%

And by floor

Same 2BR, time-controlled to today — higher floors, higher clears.

Floors 6–10 7 sales
$931,084
+7%
Floors 1–5 9 sales
$820,000
-5%

The 2BR trajectory

Every recorded 2BR. The building trades thinly year to year, so the story is the long arc, not any single year: 2BRs have moved from roughly $652K in the mid-2000s to about $866K today.

Each dot is one recorded sale, by close date and price; the line is the median for each year. Click any dot to jump straight to that sale below.

$450K$1.05M$1.65M'04'15'2510B · $810,000 · '255D · $715,044 · '249J · $922,250 · '232C · $1,480,000 · '232B · $845,000 · '2210L · $920,000 · '221J · $799,000 · '218C · $1,225,000 · '211D · $680,000 · '214D · $800,000 · '212D · $792,500 · '218L · $705,000 · '2111L · $755,000 · '2110C · $1,162,500 · '208D · $860,000 · '203C · $1,210,000 · '203L · $850,000 · '203J · $778,500 · '1910D · $825,000 · '197K · $1,254,750 · '196B · $890,000 · '1910K · $1,200,000 · '195C · $1,550,000 · '195L · $860,000 · '1811D · $975,000 · '182J · $804,000 · '186D · $800,000 · '182L · $805,000 · '181J · $822,437 · '179J · $970,000 · '1710J · $960,000 · '1712J · $986,000 · '177K · $1,110,038 · '1710L · $957,734 · '175C · $1,250,000 · '168C · $1,150,000 · '163C · $1,420,733 · '162D · $827,000 · '155K · $1,275,000 · '154C · $1,176,300 · '148D · $730,000 · '141D · $650,000 · '145C · $1,160,000 · '146J · $709,500 · '144D · $677,000 · '1310D · $699,500 · '1310K · $1,095,000 · '133J · $625,000 · '132J · $575,000 · '136L · $585,000 · '132B · $649,999 · '1312J · $645,000 · '134B · $625,000 · '134B · $625,000 · '139B · $642,000 · '139C · $1,009,000 · '134K · $1,034,255 · '133L · $618,000 · '129K · $940,000 · '1211F · $637,500 · '1212L · $637,500 · '122D · $605,000 · '124L · $617,167 · '1111J · $656,000 · '116B · $565,000 · '119B · $549,000 · '106C · $919,759 · '1010C · $930,000 · '104B · $557,500 · '105J · $550,000 · '106J · $607,500 · '093L · $550,000 · '096D · $675,000 · '0910D · $672,000 · '086B · $688,000 · '088D · $610,000 · '0812J · $749,069 · '085AB · $1,400,000 · '081D · $680,000 · '082C · $985,000 · '0712B · $735,000 · '0711F · $587,000 · '0710J · $660,000 · '074C · $1,100,000 · '079C · $1,090,000 · '0712L · $690,000 · '0612C · $603,736 · '0610K · $1,083,327 · '066J · $680,000 · '0611J · $851,679 · '0510C · $855,000 · '051D · $609,425 · '0512K · $615,958 · '056B · $643,114 · '054B · $560,000 · '052B · $560,000 · '0510D · $600,000 · '054D · $515,000 · '052L · $517,000 · '046D · $559,000 · '042K · $715,000 · '04

Lines that traded more than once

The building’s appreciation arc, apartment by apartment — recorded prices, exact.

2L+56%
$517,000 2004 → $805,000 2018
4D+55%
$515,000 2005 → $677,000 2013 → $800,000 2021
3L+55%
$550,000 2009 → $618,000 2012 → $850,000 2020
2B+51%
$560,000 2005 → $649,999 2013 → $845,000 2022
2C+50%
$985,000 2007 → $1,480,000 2023
10J+45%
$660,000 2007 → $960,000 2017
6D+43%
$559,000 2004 → $675,000 2009 → $800,000 2018
8D+41%
$610,000 2008 → $730,000 2014 → $860,000 2020
2J+40%
$575,000 2013 → $804,000 2018
10D+38%
$600,000 2005 → $672,000 2008 → $699,500 2013 → $825,000 2019
6B+38%
$643,114 2005 → $688,000 2008 → $565,000 2011 → $890,000 2019
10C+36%
$855,000 2005 → $930,000 2010 → $1,162,500 2020
12J+32%
$749,069 2008 → $645,000 2013 → $986,000 2017
2D+31%
$605,000 2012 → $827,000 2015 → $792,500 2021
3J+25%
$625,000 2013 → $778,500 2019
11C+22%
$706,783 2006 → $860,000 2022
1K+21%
$898,563 2005 → $1,085,000 2022
9B+17%
$549,000 2010 → $642,000 2013
3H+14%
$526,666 2014 → $599,000 2017
7K+13%
$1,110,038 2017 → $1,254,750 2019
2H+13%
$529,348 2006 → $525,000 2008 → $598,000 2015
1D+12%
$609,425 2005 → $680,000 2008 → $650,000 2014 → $680,000 2021
4B+12%
$560,000 2005 → $557,500 2010 → $625,000 2013 → $625,000 2013
8C+7%
$1,150,000 2016 → $1,225,000 2021

Every recorded sale

Sort any column; filter by unit or keyword. Prices are the recorded transfer amount at the NYC Department of Finance.

147 recorded sales
Apartment
Mar 5, 202610K3 BR · 2 BA$1,115,000-2.2%
Dec 30, 20259I5 BR · 1 BA$540,000-9.8%
Nov 20, 202510B2 BR · 1 BA$810,000+1.4%
Jul 31, 20257E5 BR · 1 BA$520,000-2.8%
Jun 25, 20259K3 BR · 2 BA$1,140,000-17.1%
May 29, 20256H1 BR · 1 BA$570,000-2.6%
Jan 23, 20256IStudio · 1 BA$535,000—
Nov 13, 20248G1 BR · 1 BA$550,000-15.3%
Oct 25, 20242F1 BR · 1 BA$535,000—
Apr 15, 20249BC4 BR · 3 BA$2,685,000-0.4%
Mar 27, 20245D2 BR · 1 BA$715,044-10.5%
Mar 26, 202410F1 BR · 1 BA$525,000-4.4%
Jul 10, 20239J2 BR · 1 BA$922,250-2.4%
Jun 15, 20232C2 BR · 2 BA$1,480,000-1.0%
Dec 8, 20225C3 BR · 2 BA$1,400,000-6.6%
Oct 28, 202211C1 BR · 1 BA$860,000-11.8%
Aug 24, 20222B2 BR · 1 BA$845,000-0.5%
Aug 22, 20225AB3 BR · 2 BA$1,850,000-5.1%
Jul 19, 20227BC$2,950,000—
Jul 11, 202210L2 BR · 1 BA$920,000+2.3%
Jul 6, 20226F1 BR · 1 BA$525,000-4.5%
May 20, 202210H1 BR · 1 BA$507,000-1.4%
Apr 5, 202211K1 BR · 1 BA$725,000—
Feb 16, 20221K3 BR · 2 BA$1,085,000-3.6%
Jan 24, 20224C3 BR · 2 BA$1,275,000—
Dec 15, 20211J2 BR · 1 BA$799,000—
Nov 17, 20218C2 BR · 2 BA$1,225,000-3.9%
Nov 8, 20211D2 BR · 1 BA$680,000-2.7%
Sep 29, 20214D2 BR · 1 BA$800,000—
Sep 9, 20212D2 BR · 1 BA$792,500-3.9%
Aug 23, 20218L2 BR · 1 BA$705,000+0.9%
Jun 10, 202111L2 BR · 1 BA$755,000-5.0%
Dec 22, 202010C2 BR · 2 BA$1,162,500-7.9%
Dec 16, 202011F1 BR · 1 BA$717,500-3.0%
Dec 14, 20208D2 BR$860,000—
Nov 19, 202011B1 BR · 1 BA$809,509-18.6%
Sep 3, 20203C2 BR · 2 BA$1,210,000—
Feb 13, 20203L2 BR$850,000—
Dec 23, 20193J2 BR · 1 BA$778,500-11.4%
Nov 13, 201910D2 BR · 1 BA$825,000-2.9%
Nov 7, 20197K2 BR · 2 BA$1,254,750-3.5%
Jun 25, 20195H1 BR$565,000-5.7%
Jun 4, 20193B1 BR · 1 BA$835,000-16.1%
May 1, 20196B2 BR · 1 BA$890,000-11.0%
Apr 30, 201910K2 BR · 2 BA$1,200,000—
Jan 15, 201911J1 BR$987,500-9.8%
Jan 4, 20195C2 BR$1,550,000-2.8%
Nov 21, 20185AB3 BR · 2 BA$1,725,000-1.4%
Nov 8, 2018PHL2 BR · 1 BA$836,000-1.6%
Nov 2, 20185L2 BR · 1 BA$860,000-3.9%
Sep 25, 201811D2 BR$975,000-15.1%
Sep 25, 201811B1 BR · 1 BA$975,000—
Sep 18, 20182J2 BR$804,000—
Jun 18, 20181L1 BR · 1 BA$600,429-13.6%
May 24, 20186D2 BR$800,000-5.8%
Jan 19, 20182L2 BR$805,000+0.8%
Dec 12, 20171J2 BR · 1 BA$822,437—
Dec 8, 20173IStudio$505,000—
Dec 1, 20179J2 BR · 1 BA$970,000—
Nov 6, 20173H1 BR$599,000—
Sep 19, 201710J2 BR · 1 BA$960,000-1.0%
Jul 19, 201712J2 BR · 1 BA$986,000+2.7%
Jun 13, 20177F1 BR$680,000-11.1%
May 23, 20177K2 BR$1,110,038—
Jan 20, 201710L2 BR · 1 BA$957,734+7.0%
Nov 30, 20165C2 BR$1,250,000-7.4%
Jul 7, 20168C2 BR$1,150,000—
Apr 8, 20163C2 BR · 2 BA$1,420,733+18.4%
Oct 20, 20152H1 BR$598,000-4.2%
Jun 30, 20152D2 BR$827,000+6.7%
Feb 11, 20155K2 BR$1,275,000-1.5%
Dec 2, 20143B1 BR$870,575+5.5%
Jul 16, 20144C2 BR$1,176,300+2.3%
Jul 7, 20148D2 BR$730,000—
Jun 16, 20143H1 BR · 1 BA$526,666+8.6%
Jun 16, 20141D2 BR$650,000—
Apr 22, 20145C2 BR$1,160,000+3.1%
Feb 26, 20146J2 BR$709,500—
Dec 4, 20134D2 BR$677,000—
Oct 18, 201310B1 BR$667,500-4.0%
Aug 9, 201310D2 BR$699,500—
Jul 23, 201310K2 BR$1,095,000—
Jul 1, 20133J2 BR$625,000-1.6%
Jun 26, 20132J2 BR$575,000—
Jun 14, 20136L2 BR$585,000-2.3%
Jun 7, 20132B2 BR · 1 BA$649,999—
Jun 4, 201312J2 BR · 1 BA$645,000-32.8%
Apr 23, 20134B2 BR$625,000-3.1%
Apr 1, 20134B2 BR$625,000—
Mar 12, 20139B2 BR$642,000-0.5%
Mar 12, 20139C2 BR$1,009,000-3.8%
Jan 23, 20134K2 BR$1,034,255+3.5%
Dec 20, 20123L2 BR$618,000—
Dec 19, 20129K2 BR$940,000-10.5%
Nov 5, 201211F2 BR$637,500—
Sep 20, 201212L2 BR$637,500—
May 21, 20122D2 BR$605,000-3.2%
Oct 28, 20114L2 BR$617,167+5.5%
Sep 13, 201111J2 BR$656,000+3.3%
Jun 21, 20117LStudio$620,000—
May 31, 20116B2 BR$565,000—
Nov 29, 20109B2 BR$549,000—
Oct 28, 20103DStudio$610,730—
Aug 31, 20106C2 BR$919,759+2.3%
Aug 25, 201010C2 BR$930,000-4.6%
Feb 17, 20104B2 BR · 1 BA$557,500-3.0%
Jan 29, 20105J2 BR$550,000—
Dec 2, 20096J2 BR$607,500-10.7%
Aug 28, 20093L2 BR$550,000-4.3%
Jan 28, 20096D2 BR$675,000—
Dec 12, 200810D2 BR$672,000-2.5%
Oct 28, 20082H1 BR$525,000—
Oct 20, 20086B2 BR$688,000-1.6%
Oct 15, 20088D2 BR$610,000-6.2%
Sep 11, 200812J2 BR$749,069+3.3%
Aug 12, 20087J1 BR$673,000-7.2%
Aug 11, 20085AB2 BR$1,400,000-2.0%
May 21, 20081D2 BR$680,000-2.7%
Oct 1, 20072C2 BR · 2 BA$985,000—
Aug 21, 200712B2 BR$735,000—
Jun 28, 200711F2 BR$587,000-2.0%
Jun 12, 200710J2 BR$660,000-5.6%
Jun 1, 20074C2 BR$1,100,000+5.3%
Mar 21, 20079C2 BR$1,090,000-0.5%
Oct 19, 20064HStudio$521,962—
Aug 23, 200612L2 BR$690,000+2.2%
Aug 18, 200610H1 BR · 1 BA$541,826—
Aug 15, 200611C1 BR · 1 BA$706,783—
Apr 27, 200612C2 BR · 1 BA$603,736—
Apr 25, 20067LStudio$708,757—
Mar 3, 20064F1 BR · 1 BA$534,061—
Feb 16, 200610K2 BR$1,083,327—
Jan 31, 20066J2 BR$680,000—
Jan 10, 20062H1 BR$529,348—
Dec 15, 20051K3 BR · 2 BA$898,563—
Sep 28, 200511J2 BR$851,679—
Jul 6, 200510C2 BR$855,000—
Jun 17, 20051D2 BR$609,425—
Jun 8, 200512K2 BR · 1 BA$615,958—
Apr 14, 20056B2 BR$643,114—
Jan 26, 20054B2 BR$560,000-3.3%
Jan 20, 20052B2 BR · 1 BA$560,000—
Jan 20, 200510D2 BR$600,000—
Jan 4, 20054D2 BR$515,000—
Nov 18, 20042L2 BR$517,000-3.4%
Oct 27, 20046D2 BR$559,000—
Aug 5, 20042K2 BR$715,000-1.4%

Sales sourced from NYC Department of Finance recorded transfers (BBL 1-01533-0122) and verified listing data. Co-op apartments are priced by unit type (bedroom count) rather than per square foot — square footage isn’t officially recorded for co-ops, and room counts carry some agent-entry inconsistency, so bedroom type is the reliable spine. Non-arms-length transfers and storage/parking are excluded; line and floor premiums are time-controlled to today’s pricing. Where transaction volume is too thin to support a figure, none is shown.

Buying or selling at The Plymouth House?

Put this data to work.

Buying here

Know what’s fair before you offer — we’ll show you where each line trades, the building’s discount-to-ask pattern, and where the value sits right now.

Selling here

Price to the building’s real trajectory, not a guess — we’ll position your line against its true comps to maximize the outcome.

Schedule a consultation →
Corey Cohen · The Roebling Team at Compass
646.939.7375 · c.cohen@compass.com