646.939.7375·
★92 Google reviews
Buildings·Butterfield House·Sold prices

37 West 12th StreetRecorded sales & closing prices

37 West 12th Street, New York, NY 10011

101 recorded transfers, 2004–2026. Sortable and searchable below.

1BR
$1.98M
median of 2 recent · '24
2BR
$2.8M
median of 13 recent · '23–'26
4BR+
$4.89M
median of 3 recent · '23–'25
Recent range
$1.7M – $5.65M
all types, last 4 yrs
Listing discount
0.9%
median, from last ask
Recorded transfers
101
2004–2026 on record

Not enough recent activity to price (shown for completeness, not quoted): Studio — last traded 2015; 3BR — last traded 2025.

The complete recorded-sale history for Butterfield House, compiled from NYC Department of Finance transfer records and verified listing data, then enriched apartment-by-apartment by The Roebling Team research desk. Priced by apartment type — the honest unit for a co-op, where square footage isn’t officially recorded.

Latest closings

2026-04 · 2BR
6G  $3,350,000
2026-01 · 2BR
3D  $2,500,000
2025-09 · 2BR
7D  $2,950,000
2025-08
PHH  $3,995,000
2025-08 · 3BR
10J  $5,650,000
2025-04 · 4BR+
3A3B  $5,100,000

The line premium — where you sit sets the price

Same-2BR prices, time-controlled to today’s dollars, split by line — exposure, light, and layout vary stack to stack within a building.

Bar = today’s 2BR price for that line; right column = premium vs. an average 2BR.

Line B 3 sales
$4,025,000
+44%
Line G 3 sales
$2,909,091
+4%
Line D 4 sales
$2,850,000
+2%
Line F 4 sales
$2,757,576
-2%
Line C 5 sales
$2,701,299
-4%

And by floor

Same 2BR, time-controlled to today — higher floors, higher clears.

Floors 11–15 3 sales
$2,909,091
+4%
Floors 6–10 9 sales
$2,996,212
+7%
Floors 1–5 9 sales
$2,585,000
-8%

The 2BR trajectory

Every recorded 2BR. The building trades thinly year to year, so the story is the long arc, not any single year: 2BRs have moved from roughly $1.5M in the mid-2000s to about $2.8M today.

Each dot is one recorded sale, by close date and price; the line is the median for each year. Click any dot to jump straight to that sale below.

$750K$2.5M$4.25M'04'15'266G · $3,350,000 · '263D · $2,500,000 · '267D · $2,950,000 · '252F · $2,400,000 · '242F · $2,600,000 · '246B · $4,025,000 · '2411C · $3,000,000 · '249C · $3,650,000 · '242B · $2,585,000 · '243C · $2,600,000 · '2411D · $2,850,000 · '245C · $2,600,000 · '2311G · $2,800,000 · '236B · $3,800,000 · '223F · $2,695,000 · '222H · $2,100,000 · '222C · $1,850,000 · '217D · $2,640,000 · '217H · $2,825,000 · '2110F · $2,600,000 · '219G · $2,340,000 · '217G · $2,000,000 · '199F · $2,900,000 · '183H · $1,725,000 · '1812G · $3,100,000 · '176K · $1,780,000 · '162F · $2,040,000 · '1612H · $1,900,000 · '166B · $3,677,500 · '164B · $2,720,000 · '162D · $2,600,000 · '154C · $2,750,000 · '158H · $2,800,000 · '157H · $2,525,000 · '149C · $2,856,000 · '145G · $2,775,000 · '138F · $1,725,000 · '1210C · $2,050,000 · '126K · $1,286,000 · '1211C · $2,200,000 · '126A · $1,800,000 · '122D · $1,450,000 · '1110F · $1,426,000 · '117D · $2,200,000 · '103F · $1,380,000 · '109D · $1,500,000 · '103G · $1,600,000 · '097B · $1,800,000 · '087D · $2,200,000 · '085G · $1,887,000 · '084H · $975,000 · '081H · $835,000 · '067D · $1,392,157 · '058G · $1,800,000 · '0511G · $1,995,000 · '049H · $1,500,000 · '049F · $1,400,000 · '042E · $1,500,000 · '04

Lines that traded more than once

The building’s appreciation arc, apartment by apartment — recorded prices, exact.

10J+112%
$2,660,000 2005 → $2,995,000 2010 → $5,650,000 2025
9F+107%
$1,400,000 2004 → $2,900,000 2018
5J+100%
$2,450,000 2005 → $3,479,000 2010 → $5,000,000 2016 → $4,895,000 2025
3F+95%
$1,380,000 2010 → $2,695,000 2022
10F+82%
$1,426,000 2011 → $2,600,000 2021
2D+79%
$1,450,000 2011 → $2,600,000 2015
5G+47%
$1,887,000 2008 → $2,775,000 2013
11G+40%
$1,995,000 2004 → $2,800,000 2023
2J+40%
$2,600,000 2007 → $3,140,000 2010 → $3,650,000 2022
6K+38%
$1,286,000 2012 → $1,780,000 2016
11C+36%
$2,200,000 2012 → $3,000,000 2024
9C+28%
$2,856,000 2014 → $3,650,000 2024
4J+24%
$4,000,000 2017 → $4,950,000 2024
2F+18%
$2,040,000 2016 → $2,600,000 2024 → $2,400,000 2024
7H+12%
$2,525,000 2014 → $2,825,000 2021
6B+9%
$3,677,500 2016 → $3,800,000 2022 → $4,025,000 2024
2K-3%
$1,295,000 2008 → $1,250,000 2012

Every recorded sale

Sort any column; filter by unit or keyword. Prices are the recorded transfer amount at the NYC Department of Finance.

101 recorded sales
Apartment
Apr 29, 20266G2 BR · 2 BA$3,350,000—
Jan 20, 20263D2 BR · 2 BA$2,500,000+9.2%
Sep 30, 20257D2 BR · 2 BA$2,950,000-1.5%
Aug 8, 2025PHH$3,995,000—
Aug 6, 202510J3 BR · 2.5 BA$5,650,000—
Apr 24, 20253A3B4 BR · 4 BA$5,100,000-15.0%
Feb 27, 20255J4 BR · 3.5 BA$4,895,000-2.0%
Dec 17, 20242F2 BR · 2 BA$2,400,000-3.8%
Oct 22, 20241K1 BR · 1 BA$1,700,000—
Sep 24, 20242F2 BR · 2 BA$2,600,000—
Sep 5, 20246B2 BR · 2 BA$4,025,000+0.8%
Aug 1, 202411C2 BR · 2 BA$3,000,000-7.7%
Jul 18, 202412H1 BR · 2 BA$1,975,000-1.2%
Jun 13, 20249C2 BR · 2 BA$3,650,000+8.1%
Jun 11, 20244J4 BR · 3.5 BA$4,950,000-0.9%
Jun 6, 20242B2 BR · 2 BA$2,585,000+7.9%
Feb 29, 20243C2 BR · 2 BA$2,600,000—
Jan 18, 202411D2 BR · 2 BA$2,850,000—
Dec 7, 20235C2 BR · 2 BA$2,600,000+4.0%
Oct 19, 2023PHC4 BR · 4 BA$7,345,000-5.8%
Jun 8, 202311G2 BR · 2 BA$2,800,000+3.9%
Feb 9, 20236E4 BR · 2.5 BA$3,610,000-2.3%
Jul 5, 20224G$2,575,000—
Jun 16, 20226B2 BR · 2 BA$3,800,000+0.1%
Mar 5, 20221K1 BR · 1 BAnon-market transfer (excluded from $/sf & trends)$650,000—
Feb 9, 20222J3 BR · 3.5 BA$3,650,000-8.6%
Feb 8, 20223F2 BR · 2 BA$2,695,000—
Jan 11, 20222H2 BR · 2 BA$2,100,000+23.5%
Sep 1, 202111E3 BR · 3 BA$5,200,000-9.6%
Jul 29, 20212C2 BR · 2 BA$1,850,000—
May 26, 20218CF4 BR · 4.5 BA$5,922,500-5.9%
May 12, 20217D2 BR · 2 BA$2,640,000-5.7%
Mar 4, 20217H2 BR · 2 BA$2,825,000-13.1%
Feb 26, 202110F2 BR$2,600,000—
Jan 12, 20219G2 BR · 2 BA$2,340,000-2.3%
Dec 18, 20197G2 BR · 2 BA$2,000,000-8.9%
Aug 20, 20199J3 BR · 2.5 BA$4,460,000-10.7%
Dec 19, 20184K1 BR$1,600,000—
Jul 25, 20189F2 BR · 2 BA$2,900,000-1.7%
Apr 24, 20183H2 BR$1,725,000-9.0%
Mar 13, 20185THE3 BR · 3 BA$3,000,000-14.2%
Dec 28, 20175E3 BR · 3 BA$3,000,000-14.2%
Jun 5, 201712G2 BR$3,100,000—
May 25, 20175K1 BR$1,700,000-6.8%
Apr 18, 20174J4 BR · 3.5 BA$4,000,000-5.9%
Oct 13, 20166K2 BR · 1 BA$1,780,000-6.1%
Oct 6, 20162F2 BR · 2 BA$2,040,000-11.1%
May 2, 20165J4 BR$5,000,000-9.1%
Apr 20, 201612H2 BR$1,900,000-35.6%
Apr 18, 20166B2 BR$3,677,500+6.6%
Apr 1, 20167J3 BR$3,700,000-17.7%
Mar 8, 20164B2 BR · 2 BA$2,720,000-4.6%
Oct 15, 20152D2 BR$2,600,000-7.1%
May 5, 20154C2 BR$2,750,000+1.9%
May 1, 20153KStudio$1,200,000—
Jan 29, 20158C$2,800,000—
Jan 9, 20158H2 BR$2,800,000+7.7%
Jul 2, 20147H2 BR · 2 BA$2,525,000+3.1%
May 20, 20149C2 BR$2,856,000+2.0%
Jan 8, 2014—$2,600,000—
Nov 25, 20137E3 BR$3,000,000-10.4%
Jul 17, 20135G2 BR$2,775,000—
Feb 25, 20138J3 BR$3,500,000-5.3%
Aug 30, 20128F2 BR$1,725,000-1.4%
Aug 27, 201210C2 BR$2,050,000—
Aug 23, 20126K2 BR$1,286,000-8.1%
Aug 16, 2012GRDNA2 BR$1,300,000—
Jul 24, 20122K1 BR$1,250,000—
Jun 29, 201211C2 BR · 2 BA$2,200,000—
Jun 27, 2012PHC4 BR$6,200,000-11.4%
May 2, 20126A2 BR$1,800,000-5.0%
Sep 22, 20112D2 BR$1,450,000-6.5%
Jul 18, 2011PHD2 BR$4,465,000-6.9%
Mar 21, 201110F2 BR$1,426,000+0.1%
Sep 22, 20102J3 BR$3,140,000-7.5%
Aug 3, 20105J4 BR$3,479,000-3.2%
Jun 15, 20107D2 BR$2,200,000—
Jun 15, 201010J3 BR$2,995,000—
May 13, 20103F2 BR$1,380,000—
Apr 6, 20106E3 BR$1,995,000—
Feb 16, 20109D2 BR$1,500,000-9.1%
Nov 6, 20093G2 BR$1,600,000-10.9%
Jul 31, 20087B2 BR$1,800,000—
May 30, 20087D2 BR$2,200,000—
Mar 5, 20085G2 BR$1,887,000—
Feb 28, 20082K1 BR$1,295,000—
Jan 28, 20084H2 BR$975,000—
Jun 28, 20076DStudio$1,700,000—
Jun 12, 20072J3 BR$2,600,000+13.3%
Jun 13, 20067K1 BR$960,000-3.9%
May 11, 20061H2 BR$835,000-7.2%
Nov 4, 20057D2 BR$1,392,157-5.0%
Oct 5, 2005PHD2 BR$2,650,000-11.5%
Jun 16, 200510J3 BR$2,660,000-11.2%
May 23, 20058G2 BR$1,800,000—
Feb 23, 20055J4 BR$2,450,000-3.9%
Dec 15, 200411G2 BR$1,995,000—
Dec 3, 20049H2 BR$1,500,000-3.2%
Jul 2, 20049F2 BR$1,400,000-6.7%
Jan 21, 20042E2 BR$1,500,000—
Oct 2, 2003GRDNA2 BR$799,000—

Sales sourced from NYC Department of Finance recorded transfers (BBL 1-00576-0025) and verified listing data. Co-op apartments are priced by unit type (bedroom count) rather than per square foot — square footage isn’t officially recorded for co-ops, and room counts carry some agent-entry inconsistency, so bedroom type is the reliable spine. Non-arms-length transfers and storage/parking are excluded; line and floor premiums are time-controlled to today’s pricing. Where transaction volume is too thin to support a figure, none is shown.

Buying or selling at Butterfield House?

Put this data to work.

Buying here

Know what’s fair before you offer — we’ll show you where each line trades, the building’s discount-to-ask pattern, and where the value sits right now.

Selling here

Price to the building’s real trajectory, not a guess — we’ll position your line against its true comps to maximize the outcome.

Schedule a consultation →
Corey Cohen · The Roebling Team at Compass
646.939.7375 · c.cohen@compass.com