Manhattan condos · below 96th $1,600/sf ▴2%Manhattan co-ops · below 96th $270K/room ▴2%Central Park perimeterPark Ave $472K/room ▴18%CPW $355K/room ▾5%Fifth Ave $501K/room ▴19%Billionaires' Row $4,313/sf ▴24%Flatiron $1,769/sf ▾3%
Full index →
646.939.7375·
★92 Google reviews
Buildings·51 Jay Street·Sold prices

51 Jay StreetRecorded sales & closing prices

51 Jay Street, Brooklyn, NY 11201

97 recorded closings, 2017–2026. Sortable and searchable below.

Recorded closings
97
Date range
2017–2026
Median $/sf
$1,358
2026 · adjusted
Listing discount
-1.4%
median, from last ask
Monthly carry/sf
$1.68
≈ $2,318/mo · last 12 mo
Price range
$894K – $6.08M
Price shift · median $/sf · floor-adjusted
Since 2017
▼ -5.7%
10-Year
▼ -5.7%
Since 2022
▼ -5.3%
1-Year
▲ +1.7%

Change in the building’s median $/sf over each window, on a floor-adjusted basis — standardized to the building’s average floor, so it reflects price rather than which floors happened to sell. This is a different method from The Roebling Index, which publishes plain medians and applies no floor adjustment; the two are not interchangeable. Floor adjustment standardizes for floor only. It does not control for condition, size, exposure, renovation or the mix of what happened to trade. (2022 marks the rate-shock inflection.) Like-for-like repeat-sale figures to follow.

The complete recorded-sale history for 51 Jay Street, compiled from NYC Department of Finance transfer records and verified listing data, then enriched apartment-by-apartment by The Roebling Team research desk.

Price per square foot over time

96 sales with a known square footage, by closing date.

$1,068$1,595$2,121'17'19'21'23'25'263G · $1,582/sf · 20173F · $1,619/sf · 20171B · $1,308/sf · 20173A · $1,443/sf · 20171G · $1,345/sf · 20173M · $1,424/sf · 20171K · $1,449/sf · 20173E · $1,612/sf · 20171O · $1,455/sf · 20171A · $1,316/sf · 20173C · $1,634/sf · 20173I · $1,504/sf · 20171F · $1,441/sf · 20172A · $1,397/sf · 20173L · $1,423/sf · 20171C · $1,483/sf · 20173O · $1,360/sf · 20173J · $1,461/sf · 20171N · $1,490/sf · 20173H · $1,550/sf · 20174O · $1,486/sf · 20172B · $1,602/sf · 20173D · $1,433/sf · 20172C · $1,534/sf · 20173K · $1,349/sf · 20174F · $1,597/sf · 20174E · $1,785/sf · 20174B · $1,625/sf · 20173B · $1,453/sf · 20174A · $1,482/sf · 20174K · $1,436/sf · 20174C · $1,687/sf · 20171I · $1,436/sf · 20174M · $1,506/sf · 20174J · $1,583/sf · 20174G · $1,640/sf · 20171H · $1,386/sf · 20171L · $1,442/sf · 20174L · $1,605/sf · 20171R · $1,447/sf · 20171E · $1,269/sf · 20174D · $1,585/sf · 20174H · $1,346/sf · 20175B · $1,518/sf · 20175F · $1,675/sf · 20175A · $1,513/sf · 20175M · $1,426/sf · 20175N · $1,432/sf · 20175O · $1,547/sf · 20175L · $1,556/sf · 20175E · $1,562/sf · 20175D · $1,568/sf · 20175K · $1,632/sf · 20174I · $1,645/sf · 2017PHB · $2,046/sf · 2017PHE · $1,959/sf · 2017PHD · $2,065/sf · 20171Q · $1,426/sf · 2017PHF · $1,840/sf · 20171D · $1,124/sf · 20185I · $1,341/sf · 20185G · $1,448/sf · 20185C · $1,441/sf · 2018PHG · $1,581/sf · 2018PHC · $1,979/sf · 20185J · $1,500/sf · 20183M · $1,516/sf · 2018$1,209/sf · 2018C · $1,490/sf · 2019PHA · $1,769/sf · 20195H · $1,416/sf · 20191M · $1,432/sf · 20191J · $1,522/sf · 20193N · $1,463/sf · 20194N · $1,494/sf · 20194K · $1,521/sf · 20191P · $1,651/sf · 20195N · $1,484/sf · 20195E · $1,375/sf · 20214D · $1,444/sf · 20214J · $1,490/sf · 2021PHE · $1,824/sf · 20213N · $1,461/sf · 20225H · $1,566/sf · 20224M · $1,398/sf · 20232A · $1,570/sf · 20234O · $1,262/sf · 20241R · $1,342/sf · 20244H · $1,501/sf · 20254S · $1,496/sf · 20254 · $1,281/sf · 20255D · $1,324/sf · 20253D · $1,338/sf · 20255J · $1,346/sf · 2026PHB · $1,900/sf · 20265K · $1,370/sf · 2026
Each dot is one recorded sale with a known interior square footage, plotted by closing date against price per square foot. The line is the median $/sf each year, adjusted to a floor-standardized (average-floor) unit — so it reflects price movement, not which floors happened to sell that year. Individual sale prices in the table below are unadjusted — and you can click any dot to jump straight to that sale.
Building average$1,358/sfevery bar sits above or below this · 0%

Premium by line

What each line’s exposure is worth — its light, outlook, and orientation — measured against the building’s average sale.

Line D 3 sales
-1%

Recent closings

The building’s 10 most recent market sales.

DateUnitApartmentPrice$/sfvs. Ask
Aug 25, 20265K1 BR · 1.5 BA · 894 sf$1,225,000$1,370-2.0%
Mar 18, 2026PHB4 BR · 4.5 BA · 2,973 sf$5,650,000$1,900-5.8%
Feb 25, 20265J3 BR · 3.5 BA · 1,757 sf$2,365,000$1,346-2.2%
Dec 19, 20253D2 BR · 2.5 BA · 1,382 sf$1,848,500$1,338-14.0%
Oct 29, 20255D2 BR · 2.5 BA · 1,382 sf$1,830,000$1,324-1.1%
Sep 12, 202542 BR · 2 BA · 1,287 sf$1,649,000$1,281-2.9%
Jun 18, 20254S1 BA · 665 sf$995,000$1,496+4.7%
Jun 17, 20254H1 BR · 1 BA · 623 sf$935,300$1,501—
Oct 16, 20241R3 BR · 3 BA · 2,421 sf$3,250,000$1,342+0.0%
Oct 3, 20244O3 BR · 3 BA · 1,664 sf$2,100,000$1,262-2.3%

The retrade record

Lines that have changed hands more than once in the public record — the building’s appreciation arc, apartment by apartment.

5H · 664 sf+11%
$940,000 ($1,416/sf) 2019 → $1,040,000 ($1,566/sf) 2022
3N · 866 sf+7%
$1,186,261 ($1,463/sf) 2019 → $1,265,000 ($1,461/sf) 2022
4K · 894 sf+6%
$1,284,013 ($1,436/sf) 2017 → $1,360,000 ($1,521/sf) 2019
3M · 1,382 sf+6%
$1,968,277 ($1,424/sf) 2017 → $2,095,000 ($1,516/sf) 2018
4H · 623 sf+5%
$894,023 ($1,346/sf) 2017 → $935,300 ($1,501/sf) 2025
5N · 866 sf+4%
$1,240,228 ($1,432/sf) 2017 → $1,285,000 ($1,484/sf) 2019
2A · 1,433 sf+0%
$2,248,296 ($1,397/sf) 2017 → $2,250,000 ($1,570/sf) 2023
PHB · 2,973 sf-7%
$6,083,005 ($2,046/sf) 2017 → $5,650,000 ($1,900/sf) 2026
3D · 1,382 sf-7%
$1,980,496 ($1,433/sf) 2017 → $1,848,500 ($1,338/sf) 2025
1R · 2,421 sf-7%
$3,503,000 ($1,447/sf) 2017 → $3,250,000 ($1,342/sf) 2024
4M · 1,395 sf-7%
$2,100,649 ($1,506/sf) 2017 → $1,950,000 ($1,398/sf) 2023
PHE · 3,016 sf-7%
$5,908,904 ($1,959/sf) 2017 → $5,500,887 ($1,824/sf) 2021
4D · 1,382 sf-9%
$2,190,255 ($1,585/sf) 2017 → $1,995,000 ($1,444/sf) 2021
5E · 1,382 sf-12%
$2,158,000 ($1,562/sf) 2017 → $1,900,000 ($1,375/sf) 2021
5K · 894 sf-16%
$1,459,152 ($1,632/sf) 2017 → $1,225,000 ($1,370/sf) 2026
5D · 1,382 sf-16%
$2,167,000 ($1,568/sf) 2017 → $1,830,000 ($1,324/sf) 2025

Every recorded sale

Sort any column; filter by unit or keyword. Prices are the recorded transfer amount at the NYC Department of Finance. Every sale sits in one of three states: counted in the building’s medians and trend; shown but excluded as a non-arms-length or nominal transfer; or shown and ⚑ flagged for review — a possible duplicate filing or an extreme $/sf outlier, held out of the statistics pending manual verification rather than allowed to move them.

97 recorded sales
Apartment
Aug 25, 20265K1 BR · 1.5 BA894$1,225,000$1,370-2.0%
Mar 18, 2026PHB4 BR · 4.5 BA2,973$5,650,000$1,900-5.8%
Feb 25, 20265J3 BR · 3.5 BA1,757$2,365,000$1,346-2.2%
Dec 19, 20253D2 BR · 2.5 BA1,382$1,848,500$1,338-14.0%
Oct 29, 20255D2 BR · 2.5 BA1,382$1,830,000$1,324-1.1%
Sep 12, 202542 BR · 2 BA1,287$1,649,000$1,281-2.9%
Jun 18, 20254S1 BA665$995,000$1,496+4.7%
Jun 17, 20254H1 BR · 1 BA623$935,300$1,501—
Oct 16, 20241R3 BR · 3 BA2,421$3,250,000$1,342+0.0%
Oct 3, 20244O3 BR · 3 BA1,664$2,100,000$1,262-2.3%
Oct 26, 20232A2 BR · 2.5 BA1,433$2,250,000$1,570—
May 24, 20234M2 BR · 2.5 BA1,395$1,950,000$1,398-2.3%
May 17, 20225H1 BR · 1 BA664$1,040,000$1,566-3.3%
Feb 4, 20223N1 BR · 1.5 BA866$1,265,000$1,461-0.8%
Oct 25, 2021PHE4 BR · 4.5 BA3,016$5,500,887$1,824-7.5%
Sep 15, 20214J3 BR · 3 BA1,752$2,610,000$1,490-12.9%
Jun 7, 20214D2 BR · 2.5 BA1,382$1,995,000$1,444+0.0%
Mar 31, 20215E2 BR · 2.5 BA1,382$1,900,000$1,375-11.4%
Nov 21, 20195N1 BR · 1.5 BA866$1,285,000$1,484-4.8%
Oct 11, 20191PSponsor Sale1,366$2,255,423$1,651—
Sep 23, 20194K1 BR · 1.5 BA894$1,360,000$1,521-4.6%
Aug 21, 20194NSponsor Sale811$1,211,717$1,494—
Aug 8, 20193NSponsor Sale1 BR · 1.5 BA811$1,186,261$1,463+1.8%
Aug 7, 20191JSponsor Sale1,321$2,011,043$1,522—
Jun 28, 20191MSponsor Sale2 BR · 2.5 BA1,451$2,078,000$1,432-3.3%
May 23, 20195H1 BR · 1 BA664$940,000$1,416-10.4%
Mar 18, 2019PHASponsor Sale4 BR · 4.5 BA2,663$4,709,915$1,769-12.0%
Feb 22, 2019CSponsor Sale1,229$1,831,784$1,490—
Sep 4, 2018—Sponsor Sale3 BR3,473$4,200,000$1,209-6.7%
Aug 30, 20183M2 BR · 2.5 BA1,382$2,095,000$1,516+0.0%
Jul 12, 20185JSponsor Sale2 BR · 3.5 BA1,757$2,635,329$1,500-1.5%
May 2, 2018PHCSponsor Sale3 BR2,023$4,003,000$1,979-5.8%
Apr 25, 2018PHGSponsor Sale3 BR1,931$3,053,000$1,581-15.1%
Apr 12, 20185CSponsor Sale3 BR1,945$2,803,000$1,441-12.7%
Feb 12, 20185GSponsor Sale3 BR2,005$2,903,000$1,448-11.5%
Jan 26, 20185ISponsor Sale3 BR2,009$2,695,000$1,341-17.1%
Jan 5, 20181DSponsor Sale4 BR2,251$2,530,000$1,124-24.5%
Dec 19, 2017PHFSponsor Sale4 BR2,663$4,900,000$1,840-4.9%
Dec 18, 20171QSponsor Sale2 BR1,609$2,294,117$1,426-3.4%
Sep 14, 2017PHDSponsor Sale3 BR2,058$4,250,000$2,065—
Aug 7, 2017PHESponsor Sale4 BR3,016$5,908,904$1,959+2.3%
Aug 1, 2017PHBSponsor Sale4 BR2,973$6,083,005$2,046+1.5%
Jun 28, 20174ISponsor Sale3 BR2,008$3,303,000$1,645-8.1%
Jun 22, 20175KSponsor Sale1 BR894$1,459,152$1,632+4.2%
Jun 20, 20175DSponsor Sale2 BR1,382$2,167,000$1,568-3.7%
Jun 19, 20175HSponsor Sale⚑ Flagged for review — recorded 894 sf disagrees with this line's 664 sf across other sales — the square footage looks mis-recorded; pending manual review894$985,666$1,103+2.1%
Jun 19, 20175ESponsor Sale2 BR1,382$2,158,000$1,562-4.5%
Jun 12, 20175LSponsor Sale2 BR1,287$2,003,000$1,556+0.1%
Jun 9, 20175OSponsor Sale2 BR1,664$2,574,136$1,547+1.3%
Jun 8, 20175MSponsor Sale2 BR1,395$1,988,642$1,426+2.0%
Jun 8, 20175NSponsor Sale1 BR866$1,240,228$1,432+2.1%
Jun 7, 20175ASponsor Sale2 BR1,570$2,375,577$1,513+3.3%
Jun 6, 20175FSponsor Sale2 BR1,382$2,314,482$1,675+2.0%
Jun 5, 20175BSponsor Sale2 BR1,369$2,078,000$1,518+0.1%
Apr 21, 20174HSponsor Sale664$894,023$1,346+2.2%
Apr 20, 20174DSponsor Sale2 BR1,382$2,190,255$1,585+2.0%
Apr 17, 20171ESponsor Sale2 BR1,306$1,657,711$1,269—
Apr 14, 20171RSponsor Sale3 BR2,421$3,503,000$1,447-1.3%
Apr 10, 20174LSponsor Sale2 BR1,287$2,065,011$1,605+11.6%
Apr 7, 20171LSponsor Sale2 BR1,609$2,319,573$1,442+2.0%
Apr 5, 20171HSponsor Sale2 BR1,306$1,810,448$1,386+2.0%
Apr 3, 20174GSponsor Sale3 BR2,005$3,288,947$1,640+2.9%
Mar 24, 20171ISponsor Sale2 BR1,579$2,268,000$1,436+8.0%
Mar 24, 20174MSponsor Sale2 BR1,395$2,100,649$1,506+3.2%
Mar 24, 20174JSponsor Sale2 BR1,752$2,772,694$1,583+2.9%
Mar 22, 20174CSponsor Sale3 BR1,945$3,281,819$1,687+2.9%
Mar 17, 20174ASponsor Sale2 BR1,570$2,326,701$1,482+3.1%
Mar 17, 20174KSponsor Sale1 BR894$1,284,013$1,436+4.6%
Mar 16, 20174BSponsor Sale1,271$2,065,011$1,625—
Mar 16, 20173BSponsor Sale2 BR1,369$1,988,642$1,453+2.0%
Mar 15, 20174ESponsor Sale1,291$2,304,299$1,785—
Mar 8, 20174FSponsor Sale2 BR1,382$2,207,379$1,597+2.0%
Mar 3, 20173KSponsor Sale1 BR894$1,205,608$1,349+2.1%
Mar 2, 20172CSponsor Sale2 BR1,695$2,599,592$1,534+1.9%
Feb 28, 20173DSponsor Sale2 BR1,382$1,980,496$1,433+2.0%
Feb 24, 20172BSponsor Sale1 BR679$1,087,836$1,602+3.6%
Feb 23, 20174OSponsor Sale2 BR1,664$2,472,311$1,486—
Feb 21, 20171NSponsor Sale3 BR1,899$2,828,698$1,490+2.9%
Feb 21, 20173HSponsor Sale1 BR1,053$1,632,254$1,550+2.0%
Feb 17, 20173JSponsor Sale2 BR1,655$2,418,342$1,461+1.8%
Feb 16, 20173OSponsor Sale2 BR1,664$2,263,569$1,360—
Feb 14, 20171CSponsor Sale3 BR1,839$2,726,873$1,483+2.9%
Feb 10, 20173LSponsor Sale2 BR1,287$1,830,813$1,423+2.0%
Feb 3, 20172ASponsor Sale2 BR1,609$2,248,296$1,397+2.0%
Feb 2, 20173ISponsor Sale2 BR1,614$2,428,000$1,504+6.4%
Feb 2, 20171FSponsor Sale3 BR1,751$2,523,223$1,441+1.9%
Feb 1, 20173CSponsor Sale3 BR1,945$3,178,976$1,634+2.9%
Jan 30, 20171ASponsor Sale2 BR1,391$1,830,813$1,316-4.9%
Jan 27, 20171OSponsor Sale3 BR1,818$2,645,413$1,455+1.9%
Jan 26, 20171KSponsor Sale3 BR2,479$3,592,386$1,449+1.9%
Jan 26, 20173ESponsor Sale2 BR1,382$2,227,931$1,612+4.4%
Jan 25, 20173MSponsor Sale2 BR1,382$1,968,277$1,424-2.3%
Jan 20, 20173ASponsor Sale2 BR1,570$2,265,606$1,443+1.8%
Jan 20, 20171GSponsor Sale3 BR1,728$2,324,664$1,345—
Jan 19, 20171BSponsor Sale2 BR1,322$1,728,988$1,308-0.6%
Jan 10, 20173FSponsor Sale2 BR1,382$2,238,113$1,619+2.0%
Jan 5, 20173GSponsor Sale3 BR2,005$3,172,000$1,582+0.9%
Sources, exclusions and how these figures are computed

Sales sourced from NYC Department of Finance recorded transfers (BBL 3-00031-7504) and verified listing data. Apartment-level facts (line, condition, asking-price context) curated and cross-verified by The Roebling Team research desk. Not all transactions cross-verify with ACRIS records — sponsor and LLC purchases sometimes record at stipulated values rather than market price; square footage from recorded condo declarations and offering plans. Storage, parking, and commercial units are excluded from all figures. Floor- and line-level $/sf are time-controlled (each sale measured against the building’s going rate at the time of sale) and expressed at today’s pricing, so they isolate the floor or line premium rather than blend two decades of market movement.

Buying or selling at 51 Jay Street?

Put this data to work.

Buying here

Know what’s fair before you offer — we’ll show you where each line trades, the building’s discount-to-ask pattern, and where the value sits right now.

Selling here

Price to the building’s real trajectory, not a guess — we’ll position your line against its true comps to maximize the outcome.

Prefer to speak directly? Schedule a consultation →
Corey Cohen, Principal · The Roebling Team at Compass
646.939.7375 · c.cohen@compass.com