Buildings·The Sutton·Sold prices

The SuttonRecorded sales & closing prices

959 First Avenue, New York, NY 10022

113 recorded closings, 2015–2026. Sortable and searchable below.

Recorded closings: 113
Date range: 2015–2026
Median $/sf: $1,809
Listing discount: -1.0%
Price range: $967K – $5.8M

Price shift · median $/sf

1-Year

▲ +0.3%

Since 2022

▼ -9.1%

10-Year

▼ -9.3%

Since 2015

▼ -9.3%

Change in the building’s median $/sf over each window, adjusted to a constant-quality (average-floor) unit so it reflects price — not which floors happened to sell. (2022 marks the rate-shock inflection.) Like-for-like repeat-sale figures to follow.

The complete recorded-sale history for The Sutton, compiled from NYC Department of Finance transfer records and verified listing data, then enriched apartment-by-apartment by The Roebling Team research desk.

Price per square foot over time

108 sales with a known square footage, by closing date.

Each dot is one recorded sale with a known interior square footage, plotted by closing date against price per square foot. The line is the median $/sf each year, adjusted to a constant-quality (average-floor) unit — so it reflects price movement, not which floors happened to sell that year. Individual sale prices in the table below are unadjusted — and you can click any dot to jump straight to that sale.

Building average$1,809/sfevery bar sits above or below this · 0%

The vertical premium

The climb in price per square foot as you rise through the building — light and views included, time-adjusted to today’s market.

Floors 21–25 3 sales

$1,951/sf+8%

Floors 11–15 5 sales

$1,726/sf-5%

Floors 6–10 3 sales

$1,616/sf-11%

Premium by line

What each line’s exposure is worth — its light, outlook, and orientation — measured against the building’s average sale.

Line D 3 sales

$1,692/sf-6%

Recent closings

The building’s 10 most recent market sales.

Date	Unit	Apartment	Price	$/sf	vs. Ask
May 13, 2026	25H	3 BR · 2.5 BA · 1,798 sf	$3,500,000	$1,947	—
Jun 17, 2025	12B	1 BR · 1 BA · 895 sf	$1,412,500	$1,578	-14.4%
Mar 28, 2025	10D	2 BR · 2.5 BA · 1,367 sf	$1,999,900	$1,463	—
Feb 28, 2024	25A	3 BR · 2.5 BA · 1,959 sf	$3,550,000	$1,812	-3.9%
Dec 20, 2023	10C	2 BR · 2 BA · 1,340 sf	$2,200,000	$1,642	-8.3%
Aug 28, 2023	21H	3 BR · 2.5 BA · 1,798 sf	$3,565,000	$1,983	-2.3%
May 31, 2023	11A	3 BR · 2.5 BA · 1,947 sf	$3,415,000	$1,754	-2.4%
Aug 3, 2022	14B	1 BR · 1 BA · 893 sf	$1,700,000	$1,904	—
Jun 6, 2022	8P	2 BR · 2.5 BA · 1,428 sf	$2,625,000	$1,838	-0.9%
Apr 27, 2022	12D	2 BR · 2.5 BA · 1,367 sf	$2,600,000	$1,902	-1.9%

The retrade record

Lines that have changed hands more than once in the public record — the building’s appreciation arc, apartment by apartment.

8P · 1,428 sf+25%

$2,100,000 ($1,471/sf) 2017 → $2,625,000 ($1,838/sf) 2022

11B · 893 sf+13%

$1,527,365 ($1,710/sf) 2016 → $1,730,000 ($1,937/sf) 2019

10B · 893 sf+11%

$1,507,000 ($1,688/sf) 2016 → $1,675,000 ($1,876/sf) 2017

16B · 893 sf+8%

$1,669,920 ($1,870/sf) 2016 → $1,800,000 ($2,016/sf) 2017

14B · 893 sf+7%

$1,594,990 ($1,786/sf) 2016 → $1,700,000 ($1,904/sf) 2022

8J · 1,965 sf+4%

$3,799,990 ($1,934/sf) 2017 → $3,945,000 ($2,008/sf) 2021

23E · 907 sf+2%

$1,771,745 ($1,953/sf) 2017 → $1,810,000 ($1,996/sf) 2019

7R · 841 sf+2%

$1,299,990 ($1,546/sf) 2015 → $1,323,715 ($1,574/sf) 2016

11A · 1,947 sf+1%

$3,390,762 ($1,742/sf) 2016 → $3,250,000 ($1,669/sf) 2019 → $3,415,000 ($1,754/sf) 2023

24B · 895 sf+0%

$1,789,564 ($2,000/sf) 2016 → $1,789,564 ($2,000/sf) 2022

21H · 1,798 sf-3%

$3,665,700 ($2,039/sf) 2018 → $3,565,000 ($1,983/sf) 2023

12D · 1,367 sf-3%

$2,672,896 ($1,955/sf) 2016 → $2,600,000 ($1,902/sf) 2022

10C · 1,340 sf-7%

$2,364,990 ($1,765/sf) 2016 → $2,364,990 ($1,765/sf) 2017 → $2,200,000 ($1,642/sf) 2023

9P · 1,428 sf-8%

$2,175,000 ($1,523/sf) 2017 → $1,995,000 ($1,397/sf) 2019

12B · 893 sf-9%

$1,547,730 ($1,733/sf) 2017 → $1,412,500 ($1,582/sf) 2025

20D · 1,370 sf-13%

$2,889,990 ($2,109/sf) 2017 → $2,525,000 ($1,843/sf) 2019

18D · 1,370 sf-14%

$2,907,094 ($2,122/sf) 2016 → $2,500,000 ($1,825/sf) 2019

25A · 1,959 sf-17%

$4,266,457 ($2,178/sf) 2017 → $3,550,000 ($1,812/sf) 2024

25H · 1,798 sf-18%

$4,281,731 ($2,381/sf) 2017 → $3,500,000 ($1,947/sf) 2026

10D · 1,367 sf-22%

$2,560,889 ($1,873/sf) 2016 → $1,999,900 ($1,463/sf) 2025

Every recorded sale

Sort any column; filter by unit or keyword. Prices are the recorded transfer amount at the NYC Department of Finance.

113 recorded sales

		Apartment
May 13, 2026	25H	3 BR · 2.5 BA	1,798	$3,500,000	$1,947	—
Dec 23, 2025	20D	2 BR · 2.5 BAnon-market transfer (excluded from $/sf & trends)	1,370	$1,400,000	—	—
Jun 17, 2025	12B	1 BR · 1 BA	895	$1,412,500	$1,578	-14.4%
Mar 28, 2025	10D	2 BR · 2.5 BA	1,367	$1,999,900	$1,463	—
Feb 28, 2024	25A	3 BR · 2.5 BA	1,959	$3,550,000	$1,812	-3.9%
Dec 20, 2023	10C	2 BR · 2 BA	1,340	$2,200,000	$1,642	-8.3%
Aug 28, 2023	21H	3 BR · 2.5 BA	1,798	$3,565,000	$1,983	-2.3%
May 31, 2023	11A	3 BR · 2.5 BA	1,947	$3,415,000	$1,754	-2.4%
Aug 3, 2022	14B	1 BR · 1 BA	893	$1,700,000	$1,904	—
Jun 6, 2022	8P	2 BR · 2.5 BA	1,428	$2,625,000	$1,838	-0.9%
Apr 27, 2022	12D	2 BR · 2.5 BA	1,367	$2,600,000	$1,902	-1.9%
Mar 17, 2022	24B	1 BR · 1 BA	—	$1,789,564	—	—
Nov 23, 2021	8J	3 BR · 2.5 BA	—	$3,945,000	—	-21.0%
Aug 11, 2021	11D	2 BR · 2.5 BA	1,367	$2,350,000	$1,719	-5.6%
Sep 15, 2020	PH1	3 BR · 3.5 BA	3,356	$5,800,000	$1,728	-35.2%
Oct 1, 2019	11B	1 BR · 1 BA	893	$1,730,000	$1,937	-5.2%
Sep 23, 2019	23E	1 BR · 1 BA	907	$1,810,000	$1,996	-1.1%
Sep 3, 2019	18D	2 BR · 2.5 BA	1,370	$2,500,000	$1,825	—
Aug 26, 2019	9P	2 BR · 2.5 BA	1,428	$1,995,000	$1,397	-11.3%
Jul 30, 2019	26L	2 BR · 2 BA	1,442	$2,850,000	$1,976	-10.9%
Jun 28, 2019	11A	3 BR · 2.5 BA	1,947	$3,250,000	$1,669	-16.2%
Apr 23, 2019	26M	4 BR · 3.5 BA	2,158	$4,499,000	$2,085	-17.6%
Mar 22, 2019	20D	2 BR · 2.5 BA	1,370	$2,525,000	$1,843	—
Feb 11, 2019	TC3	2 BR · 2.5 BA	1,926	$4,799,000	$2,492	-4.0%
Jan 24, 2019	7RR	1 BR	841	$1,410,000	$1,677	-4.4%
Jan 17, 2019	TC1	2 BR · 2.5 BA	1,947	$4,700,000	$2,414	-6.0%
Sep 14, 2018	TC2	3 BR · 2.5 BA	2,272	$5,675,000	$2,498	-0.4%
Aug 31, 2018	26A	3 BR · 2.5 BA	1,959	$4,307,187	$2,199	+1.8%
Jun 27, 2018	22H	3 BR	1,798	$3,800,000	$2,113	+1.3%
Apr 13, 2018	23H	3 BR	1,798	$3,700,000	$2,058	-2.5%
Mar 23, 2018	6T	3 BR	2,472	$3,715,000	$1,503	-2.7%
Mar 16, 2018	21A	3 BR	1,959	$3,535,270	$1,805	-5.6%
Mar 12, 2018	16A	3 BR	1,959	$3,487,506	$1,780	-2.4%
Mar 9, 2018	18A	3 BR	1,959	$3,500,000	$1,787	-3.7%
Feb 23, 2018	7P	2 BR	1,425	$2,153,599	$1,511	-1.0%
Feb 14, 2018	17D	2 BR	1,370	$2,545,615	$1,858	+1.8%
Jan 10, 2018	21H	3 BR	1,798	$3,665,700	$2,039	-0.9%
Nov 20, 2017	16B	1 BR	893	$1,800,000	$2,016	-4.5%
Nov 15, 2017	20A	3 BR	1,959	$3,525,000	$1,799	-5.0%
Nov 14, 2017	8P	2 BR	1,428	$2,100,000	$1,471	-11.0%
Oct 31, 2017	9P	2 BR	1,428	$2,175,000	$1,523	-1.6%
Oct 20, 2017	24A	3 BR	1,959	$4,050,000	$2,067	-2.4%
Aug 14, 2017	12C		1,340	$2,469,246	$1,843	—
Jul 25, 2017	6G	3 BR	2,472	$4,072,990	$1,648	-5.9%
Apr 28, 2017	15C	2 BR	1,340	$2,514,990	$1,877	—
Apr 26, 2017	23A		2,897	$5,725,000	$1,976	—
Apr 4, 2017	19A	non-market transfer (excluded from $/sf & trends)	—	$5,427,481	—	—
Mar 31, 2017	11C		1,340	$2,394,990	$1,787	—
Mar 30, 2017	25B		895	$1,869,990	$2,089	—
Mar 28, 2017	10B	1 BR · 1 BA	893	$1,675,000	$1,876	-6.2%
Mar 16, 2017	20D	2 BR	1,370	$2,889,990	$2,109	—
Mar 16, 2017	10C	2 BR	1,340	$2,364,990	$1,765	—
Mar 16, 2017	8J	3 BR	1,965	$3,799,990	$1,934	—
Feb 24, 2017	10A	3 BR	1,947	$3,299,990	$1,695	—
Feb 14, 2017	19C	2 BR	1,349	$2,708,535	$2,008	+1.8%
Feb 13, 2017	25E	1 BR	907	$1,796,232	$1,980	-1.0%
Feb 7, 2017	25H	3 BR	1,798	$4,281,731	$2,381	+3.7%
Jan 31, 2017	16D	2 BR	1,370	$2,650,000	$1,934	-0.7%
Jan 31, 2017	22A	3 BR	1,959	$3,999,000	$2,041	-1.7%
Jan 30, 2017	8F	1 BR	799	$1,262,620	$1,580	+1.8%
Jan 27, 2017	23E	1 BR	907	$1,771,745	$1,953	+1.8%
Jan 24, 2017	21B	1 BR	895	$1,789,990	$2,000	+1.7%
Jan 24, 2017	22B		895	$1,809,990	$2,022	—
Jan 18, 2017	14A	3 BR	—	$3,742,059	—	+1.1%
Jan 17, 2017	17B	1 BR	895	$1,710,650	$1,911	+1.8%
Jan 17, 2017	24E	1 BR	907	$1,822,657	$2,010	+1.8%
Jan 6, 2017	12B	1 BR	893	$1,547,730	$1,733	+1.2%
Jan 6, 2017	25A	3 BR	1,959	$4,266,457	$2,178	+1.8%
Dec 28, 2016	9L	2 BR	1,376	$2,459,064	$1,787	+5.1%
Dec 27, 2016	13B	1 BR	893	$1,603,734	$1,796	+1.8%
Dec 27, 2016	20B	1 BR	895	$1,781,927	$1,991	+1.8%
Dec 23, 2016	13A	3 BR	1,947	$3,580,000	$1,839	-2.2%
Dec 22, 2016	10B	1 BR · 1 BA	893	$1,507,000	$1,688	—
Dec 20, 2016	11A	3 BR	1,947	$3,390,762	$1,742	+1.8%
Dec 20, 2016	13C		1,340	$2,359,794	$1,761	—
Dec 19, 2016	24B	1 BR	895	$1,789,564	$2,000	-3.3%
Dec 19, 2016	15D	2 BR	1,367	$2,713,626	$1,985	+1.8%
Dec 15, 2016	15B	1 BR	893	$1,619,007	$1,813	+1.8%
Dec 14, 2016	6F	1 BR	827	$1,277,500	$1,545	+6.5%
Dec 14, 2016	6P	2 BR	1,514	$2,390,170	$1,579	+3.0%
Dec 9, 2016	7F	1 BR	799	$1,282,985	$1,606	+1.8%
Dec 7, 2016	18B	1 BR	895	$1,654,810	$1,849	-3.0%
Dec 7, 2016	19D	2 BR	1,370	$2,861,272	$2,089	+1.8%
Dec 2, 2016	17C	2 BR	1,349	$2,754,356	$2,042	+5.9%
Nov 23, 2016	16C	2 BR	1,349	$2,539,990	$1,883	-2.3%
Nov 21, 2016	14D	2 BR	1,367	$2,657,622	$1,944	+1.8%
Nov 18, 2016	9F	1 BR	799	$1,282,985	$1,606	+1.8%
Nov 17, 2016	14C	2 BR	1,340	$2,504,885	$1,869	+1.8%
Nov 17, 2016	18C	2 BR	1,349	$2,655,000	$1,968	+1.0%
Nov 16, 2016	15A	3 BR	1,947	$3,808,245	$1,956	+1.8%
Nov 9, 2016	22E	1 BR	907	$1,749,990	$1,929	—
Nov 7, 2016	7R	1 BR	841	$1,323,715	$1,574	+3.4%
Nov 4, 2016	11B	1 BR	893	$1,527,365	$1,710	+1.8%
Nov 4, 2016	9K	2 BR	1,155	$2,000,000	$1,732	-6.5%
Oct 31, 2016	14B	1 BR	893	$1,594,990	$1,786	+1.6%
Oct 28, 2016	18D	2 BR	1,370	$2,907,094	$2,122	+4.6%
Oct 26, 2016	12D	2 BR	1,367	$2,672,896	$1,955	+4.8%
Oct 26, 2016	13D	2 BR	1,367	$2,550,953	$1,866	-2.1%
Oct 24, 2016	7X	1 BR	739	$1,140,430	$1,543	+1.8%
Oct 24, 2016	8X	1 BR	742	$1,160,795	$1,564	+1.8%
Oct 20, 2016	8S		572	$967,327	$1,691	+1.8%
Oct 19, 2016	6X	1 BR	739	$1,160,795	$1,571	+5.5%
Oct 18, 2016	9X	1 BR	742	$1,308,441	$1,763	+8.1%
Oct 17, 2016	20C	2 BR	1,349	$2,815,451	$2,087	+4.7%
Oct 14, 2016	7K	2 BR	1,384	$2,331,782	$1,685	+1.8%
Oct 14, 2016	10C	2 BR	1,340	$2,364,990	$1,765	—
Oct 13, 2016	12A	3 BR	1,947	$3,421,310	$1,757	+1.8%
Oct 13, 2016	10D	2 BR · 2.5 BA	1,367	$2,560,889	$1,873	-5.0%
Oct 5, 2016	16B	1 BR	893	$1,669,920	$1,870	+1.8%
Sep 29, 2016	21E	1 BR	907	$1,731,015	$1,909	+1.8%
Sep 27, 2016	17A	3 BR	1,959	$3,800,000	$1,940	-1.8%
Sep 26, 2016	24H	3 BR	1,798	$4,210,454	$2,342	+1.8%
Apr 18, 2015	7R	1 BR	841	$1,299,990	$1,546	+1.6%

Sales sourced from NYC Department of Finance recorded transfers (BBL 1-01345-7502) and verified listing data. Apartment-level facts (line, condition, asking-price context) curated and cross-verified by The Roebling Team research desk. Not all transactions cross-verify with ACRIS records — sponsor and LLC purchases sometimes record at stipulated values rather than market price; square footage from recorded condo declarations and offering plans. Storage, parking, and commercial units are excluded from all figures. Floor- and line-level $/sf are time-controlled (each sale measured against the building’s going rate at the time of sale) and expressed at today’s pricing, so they isolate the floor or line premium rather than blend two decades of market movement.

Buying or selling at The Sutton?

Put this data to work.

Buying here

Know what’s fair before you offer — we’ll show you where each line trades, the building’s discount-to-ask pattern, and where the value sits right now.

Selling here

Price to the building’s real trajectory, not a guess — we’ll position your line against its true comps to maximize the outcome.

Schedule a consultation →

Corey Cohen, Principal · The Roebling Team at Compass
646.939.7375 · c.cohen@compass.com