Carnegie Hill Tower (1327 Madison Avenue / 40 East 94th Street)Recorded sales & closing prices

1327 Madison Avenue, New York, NY 10128

173 recorded closings, 2003–2026. Sortable and searchable below.

Recorded closings
173
Date range
2003–2026
Median $/sf
$1,282
2026 · adjusted
Listing discount
5.1%
median, from last ask
Price range
$560K – $13.8M
Price shift · median $/sf · constant-quality
Since 2003
+48.3%
10-Year
-9.4%
Since 2022
-6.1%
1-Year
-1.3%

Change in the building’s median $/sf over each window, adjusted to a constant-quality (average-floor) unit so it reflects price — not which floors happened to sell. (2022 marks the rate-shock inflection.) Like-for-like repeat-sale figures to follow.

Carnegie Hill Tower trades as a view-capable, full-service Carnegie Hill condominium where floor and exposure drive value as much as the apartment itself, and where the condominium structure widens the buyer pool relative to the neighborhood's prewar co-ops. Pricing runs unit-by-unit: higher floors and south- and west-facing lines with open exposures carry premiums over lower and interior lines. Recorded sales auto-populate from public records; unit-level history and current same-line comparables are maintained in The Roebling Research Library and shared with clients during diligence. Same-line, same-floor comparables — not building averages — are the correct basis in a 32-story tower.

The complete recorded-sale history for Carnegie Hill Tower, compiled from NYC Department of Finance transfer records and verified listing data, then enriched apartment-by-apartment by The Roebling Team research desk. Across sales with a public asking price, the building carries a median listing discount of 5.1% from the last ask — a recurring negotiation gap worth pricing into any offer or listing strategy here.

Price per square foot over time

157 sales with a known square footage, by closing date.

$390$2,560$4,730'03'07'11'15'19'23'2617F · $717/sf · 200310A · $808/sf · 200328C · $1,181/sf · 20033K · $622/sf · 200415C · $761/sf · 200426G · $651/sf · 200414B · $942/sf · 20049B · $950/sf · 20044H · $893/sf · 20048A · $864/sf · 20044K · $931/sf · 200530B · $1,365/sf · 20058B · $846/sf · 200512F · $2,223/sf · 20054E · $1,066/sf · 200517D · $3,678/sf · 200529G · $1,085/sf · 200517G · $1,076/sf · 20056D · $1,886/sf · 200527F · $3,439/sf · 20053F/G · $2,335/sf · 200528F · $1,099/sf · 200517CD · $1,458/sf · 200525C · $1,346/sf · 2005D · $1,182/sf · 200532C · $1,470/sf · 200513A · $1,153/sf · 200615D · $1,135/sf · 20065C · $953/sf · 200617C/D · $1,000/sf · 20064E · $1,031/sf · 200622F · $2,179/sf · 200611B · $1,181/sf · 20065G · $1,377/sf · 200614E · $990/sf · 200611F · $1,072/sf · 200623F · $1,383/sf · 200621F · $1,142/sf · 20063C · $2,481/sf · 200612E · $1,008/sf · 20062B · $2,300/sf · 20065A · $1,074/sf · 20077C · $895/sf · 20073M · $1,073/sf · 200720E · $1,052/sf · 20073D · $1,091/sf · 20077D · $1,057/sf · 2007B · $1,033/sf · 200729D · $1,241/sf · 200717B · $1,519/sf · 200829B · $923/sf · 200830D · $800/sf · 200810A · $1,378/sf · 20084E · $1,502/sf · 20088F · $1,093/sf · 200821F · $1,470/sf · 200817E · $872/sf · 200928ABC · $1,522/sf · 20093J · $880/sf · 20094G · $919/sf · 201011G · $1,282/sf · 201017G · $1,428/sf · 20107A · $1,400/sf · 201122BC · $1,876/sf · 201122A · $1,667/sf · 201122A/22G · $1,523/sf · 201110A · $1,378/sf · 201124D · $1,224/sf · 20114J · $903/sf · 201112B · $2,832/sf · 201121C · $1,832/sf · 201115D · $1,161/sf · 201224F/G · $1,807/sf · 20127C · $1,202/sf · 20126CD · $1,418/sf · 201218C · $1,527/sf · 20123F · $1,369/sf · 20129D · $1,142/sf · 201216CD · $1,626/sf · 201226F · $793/sf · 20124A · $881/sf · 201226C · $3,045/sf · 20127E · $1,029/sf · 20132HJ · $1,489/sf · 201415E · $1,265/sf · 201431D · $1,730/sf · 201415F · $973/sf · 201431C · $3,126/sf · 20148B · $1,458/sf · 20142D · $1,250/sf · 20147D · $3,688/sf · 201517G · $1,426/sf · 201517CD · $2,210/sf · 20158E · $1,169/sf · 20153A · $1,084/sf · 20159E · $990/sf · 201523F · $1,800/sf · 20164C · $1,374/sf · 201627CD · $2,200/sf · 201628F · $1,844/sf · 201613A · $1,943/sf · 201628ABC · $2,989/sf · 20162F · $1,120/sf · 201725F · $1,556/sf · 201714D · $1,401/sf · 201722B · $4,497/sf · 201713G · $1,229/sf · 201713/G · $1,275/sf · 20176G · $1,283/sf · 201729G · $1,591/sf · 20173H · $1,195/sf · 201732D · $1,677/sf · 201717G · $1,429/sf · 201718E · $1,307/sf · 201810F · $1,321/sf · 201811DE · $1,453/sf · 20183A · $1,481/sf · 201810CDE · $1,450/sf · 201824D · $1,600/sf · 201811B · $1,308/sf · 202030B · $1,962/sf · 202017F · $1,357/sf · 202010G · $1,056/sf · 20218A · $1,098/sf · 202121G · $1,121/sf · 20214D · $2,956/sf · 20214C · $1,322/sf · 20219DE · $1,472/sf · 20219A · $1,372/sf · 202125B · $1,756/sf · 202122B · $2,106/sf · 202126B · $1,481/sf · 202229E/F · $1,491/sf · 202213B · $1,346/sf · 202227A · $1,729/sf · 202218A · $1,249/sf · 202215F · $1,329/sf · 20229F · $1,304/sf · 20222HJ · $1,556/sf · 202215B · $1,269/sf · 20234M · $1,134/sf · 202326CDE · $1,665/sf · 202322A · $2,047/sf · 202316G · $1,393/sf · 202320BCDE · $1,487/sf · 202421E · $1,331/sf · 202415B · $1,319/sf · 202410B · $1,415/sf · 20256B · $1,276/sf · 20254G · $1,019/sf · 202517A · $1,537/sf · 202510F · $1,268/sf · 2025E · $915/sf · 202511A · $1,427/sf · 202620F · $1,321/sf · 20266F · $1,000/sf · 20263D · $1,137/sf · 2026
Each dot is one recorded sale with a known interior square footage, plotted by closing date against price per square foot. The line is the median $/sf each year, adjusted to a constant-quality (average-floor) unit — so it reflects price movement, not which floors happened to sell that year. Individual sale prices in the table below are unadjusted — and you can click any dot to jump straight to that sale.
Building average$1,282/sfevery bar sits above or below this · 0%

The vertical premium

The climb in price per square foot as you rise through the building — light and views included, time-adjusted to today’s market.

Floors 26–30 4 sales
$1,663/sf+30%
Floors 21–25 5 sales
$1,663/sf+30%
Floors 16–20 6 sales
$1,331/sf+4%
Floors 11–15 6 sales
$1,253/sf-2%
Floors 6–10 9 sales
$1,234/sf-4%
Floors 1–5 6 sales
$1,199/sf-6%

Premium by line

What each line’s exposure is worth — its light, outlook, and orientation — measured against the building’s average sale.

Line A 7 sales
$1,438/sf+12%
Line B 10 sales
$1,326/sf+3%
Line F 6 sales
$1,240/sf-3%
Line G 4 sales
$1,031/sf-20%

Recent closings

The building’s 10 most recent market sales.

DateUnitApartmentPrice$/sfvs. Ask
Jun 23, 20263D1 BR · 1 BA · 871 sf$990,000$1,137-23.8%
Jun 15, 20266F2 BR · 2 BA · 1,400 sf$1,400,000$1,000-4.8%
May 28, 202620F2 BR · 2 BA · 1,400 sf$1,850,000$1,321
May 27, 20263E2 BR · 2 BA$1,525,000-4.7%
Apr 1, 202618B2 BR · 2 BA$2,125,000-2.3%
Feb 12, 202611A3 BR · 3 BA · 1,822 sf$2,600,000$1,427-4.6%
Sep 5, 2025E1,016 sf$930,000$915
Jul 14, 202510F2 BR · 2 BA · 1,400 sf$1,775,000$1,268-11.0%
Jun 23, 202517A3 BR · 3 BA · 1,822 sf$2,800,000$1,537+6.7%
Jun 13, 20254G1 BR · 1 BA · 967 sf$985,000$1,019-1.0%

The retrade record

Lines that have changed hands more than once in the public record — the building’s appreciation arc, apartment by apartment. Showing the 24 strongest of 27 repeat-trade lines; sort the table below by Unit to see every line’s full history.

28ABC · 4,600 sf+96%
$7,000,000 ($1,522/sf) 2009$13,750,000 ($2,989/sf) 2016
17F · 1,400 sf+91%
$995,000 ($717/sf) 2003$1,900,000 ($1,357/sf) 2020
10A · 1,850 sf+71%
$1,495,000 ($808/sf) 2003$2,550,000 ($1,378/sf) 2008$2,550,000 ($1,378/sf) 2011
13A · 1,822 sf+69%
$2,100,000 ($1,153/sf) 2006$3,540,000 ($1,943/sf) 2016
28F · 1,388 sf+68%
$1,525,000 ($1,099/sf) 2005$2,560,000 ($1,844/sf) 2016
17CD · 2,260 sf+52%
$3,295,000 ($1,458/sf) 2005$4,995,000 ($2,210/sf) 2015
29G · 1,383 sf+47%
$1,500,000 ($1,085/sf) 2005$2,200,000 ($1,591/sf) 2017
8B+45%
$1,100,000 ($846/sf) 2005$1,895,000 ($1,458/sf) 2014$1,595,000 2023
30B · 1,300 sf+44%
$1,775,000 ($1,365/sf) 2005$2,550,000 ($1,962/sf) 2020
4E · 1,032 sf+41%
$1,100,000 ($1,066/sf) 2005$1,134,250 ($1,031/sf) 2006$1,550,000 ($1,502/sf) 2008
15F · 1,388 sf+37%
$1,350,000 ($973/sf) 2014$1,845,000 ($1,329/sf) 2022
3A · 783 sf+36%
$850,000 ($1,084/sf) 2015$1,160,000 ($1,481/sf) 2018
17G · 1,400 sf+34%
$1,488,000 ($1,076/sf) 2005$1,975,000 ($1,428/sf) 2010$1,975,000 ($1,426/sf) 2015$2,000,000 ($1,429/sf) 2017
7C · 1,310 sf+34%
$1,173,000 ($895/sf) 2007$1,575,000 ($1,202/sf) 2012
21E · 750 sf+33%
$750,000 2013$998,000 ($1,331/sf) 2024
24D · 875 sf+31%
$1,065,000 ($1,224/sf) 2011$1,400,000 ($1,600/sf) 2018
23F · 1,388 sf+30%
$1,920,000 ($1,383/sf) 2006$2,498,000 ($1,800/sf) 2016
21F · 1,388 sf+29%
$1,585,000 ($1,142/sf) 2006$2,040,000 ($1,470/sf) 2008
8A · 1,822 sf+27%
$1,575,000 ($864/sf) 2004$2,000,000 ($1,098/sf) 2021
15A+21%
$1,895,000 2004$2,300,000 2007
11B · 1,300 sf+7%
$1,595,000 ($1,181/sf) 2006$1,700,000 ($1,308/sf) 2020
15D · 870 sf+5%
$965,000 ($1,135/sf) 2006$1,010,000 ($1,161/sf) 2012
3D · 871 sf+4%
$950,000 ($1,091/sf) 2007$990,000 ($1,137/sf) 2026
15B · 1,300 sf+4%
$1,650,000 ($1,269/sf) 2023$1,715,000 ($1,319/sf) 2024

Every recorded sale

Sort any column; filter by unit or keyword. Prices are the recorded transfer amount at the NYC Department of Finance. Every sale sits in one of three states: counted in the building’s medians and trend; shown but excluded as a non-arms-length or nominal transfer; or shown and ⚑ flagged for review — a possible duplicate filing or an extreme $/sf outlier, held out of the statistics pending manual verification rather than allowed to move them.

173 recorded sales
Apartment
Jun 23, 20263D1 BR · 1 BA871$990,000$1,137-23.8%
Jun 15, 20266F2 BR · 2 BA1,400$1,400,000$1,000-4.8%
May 28, 202620F2 BR · 2 BA1,400$1,850,000$1,321
May 27, 20263E2 BR · 2 BA$1,525,000-4.7%
Apr 1, 202618B2 BR · 2 BA$2,125,000-2.3%
Feb 12, 202611A3 BR · 3 BA1,822$2,600,000$1,427-4.6%
Sep 5, 2025E1,016$930,000$915
Jul 14, 202510F2 BR · 2 BA1,400$1,775,000$1,268-11.0%
Jun 23, 202517A3 BR · 3 BA1,822$2,800,000$1,537+6.7%
Jun 13, 20254G1 BR · 1 BA967$985,000$1,019-1.0%
Apr 21, 20256B2 BR · 2 BA1,360$1,735,000$1,276-2.3%
Jan 15, 202510B2 BR · 2 BA1,360$1,925,000$1,415-3.5%
Oct 4, 202415B2 BR · 2 BA1,300$1,715,000$1,319
May 23, 202421E1 BR · 1 BA750$998,000$1,331-7.2%
May 20, 202420BCDE4 BR · 5 BA4,200$6,245,000$1,487-3.9%
Dec 18, 202316G2 BR · 2 BA1,400$1,950,000$1,393+5.4%
Nov 13, 202326CDE4 BR · 4 BA3,000$4,995,000$1,665-19.4%
Nov 13, 202322A3 BR1,383$2,830,596$2,047
Oct 10, 20234M5 BR · 1 BA573$650,000$1,134-5.1%
Sep 19, 20238B2 BR · 2 BA$1,595,000-6.2%
Mar 14, 202315B2 BR · 2 BA1,300$1,650,000$1,269-12.0%
Dec 7, 20222HJ5 BR · 3 BA2,250$3,500,000$1,556+2.2%
Nov 22, 20229F2 BR · 2 BA1,400$1,825,000$1,304-3.9%
Nov 21, 202215F2 BR · 2 BA1,388$1,845,000$1,329
Aug 18, 202218A2 BR · 2 BA1,822$2,275,000$1,249-8.8%
Jul 11, 202227A3 BR · 3 BA1,822$3,150,000$1,729-19.1%
Feb 8, 202213B2 BR · 2 BA1,300$1,750,000$1,346
Feb 2, 202229E/F3 BR · 3.5 BA2,200$3,280,000$1,491-6.2%
Jan 21, 202226B1 BR · 2 BA1,300$1,925,000$1,481-8.3%
Dec 28, 202122B4 BR · 3 BA2,612$5,500,000$2,106-4.3%
Nov 15, 202125B3 BR · 2 BA1,680$2,950,000$1,756-7.8%
Sep 30, 20219A1,822$2,500,000$1,372
Jun 18, 20219DE3 BR · 3 BA1,600$2,355,000$1,472-0.8%
May 7, 20214C2 BR · 2 BA1,312$1,735,000$1,322-13.0%
May 6, 20214D871$2,575,000$2,956
Apr 30, 202121G2 BR · 2 BA1,383$1,550,000$1,121-13.9%
Apr 22, 20218A3 BR · 3 BA1,822$2,000,000$1,098
Feb 9, 202110G2 BR · 2 BA1,383$1,460,000$1,056-11.5%
May 29, 20205D1 BR · 1 BA$1,075,000-12.2%
Mar 3, 202017F2 BR · 2 BA1,400$1,900,000$1,357-11.6%
Feb 21, 202030B2 BR · 2 BA1,300$2,550,000$1,962
Feb 20, 202011B2 BR · 2 BA1,300$1,700,000$1,308-8.1%
Feb 3, 202027B2 BR · 2 BA$2,450,000-9.1%
Jun 11, 20192HJ5 BR · 3 BA$3,200,000-13.5%
Nov 8, 201824D1 BR · 1 BA875$1,400,000$1,600-6.0%
Oct 4, 201832C3 BRnon-market transfer (excluded from $/sf & trends)2,143$1,600,000
Aug 10, 201810CDE4 BR · 3 BA3,000$4,350,000$1,450-20.8%
Jul 18, 20183A1 BR · 1.5 BA783$1,160,000$1,481-2.9%
Jun 28, 201811DE2 BR · 2 BA1,600$2,325,000$1,453-3.1%
Apr 9, 201810F2 BR · 2 BA1,400$1,850,000$1,321-5.1%
Jan 31, 201818E1 BR727$950,000$1,307-4.5%
Sep 28, 201717G2 BR · 2 BA1,400$2,000,000$1,429-4.8%
Aug 17, 2017PHD323 BR$2,900,000-26.6%
Aug 15, 201732D1,729$2,900,000$1,677
Jul 27, 20173H2 BR1,381$1,650,000$1,195-8.1%
Jul 13, 201729G2 BR1,383$2,200,000$1,591-2.2%
May 19, 20176G2 BR1,383$1,775,000$1,283-9.0%
Apr 28, 201713G2 BR1,383$1,700,000$1,229-30.6%
Apr 28, 201713/G2 BR1,333$1,700,000$1,275-12.6%
Apr 21, 201722B4 BR · 3 BA1,312$5,900,000$4,497
Mar 9, 201714D1 BR870$1,218,600$1,401-5.9%
Mar 1, 201725F2 BR1,388$2,160,000$1,556-15.3%
Feb 15, 20172F1 BR920$1,030,000$1,120-10.4%
Jun 29, 201628ABC5 BR · 4 BA4,600$13,750,000$2,989
Jun 22, 201613A3 BR · 3 BA1,822$3,540,000$1,943-11.4%
Jun 17, 201628F2 BR1,388$2,560,000$1,844-3.4%
May 10, 201627CD3 BR2,182$4,800,000$2,200-20.0%
Mar 23, 20164C2 BR · 2 BA1,383$1,900,000$1,374
Mar 1, 201623F2 BR1,388$2,498,000$1,800-0.1%
Dec 18, 20159E727$720,000$990
Dec 11, 20153A1 BR784$850,000$1,084-5.5%
Nov 23, 20158E1 BR · 1 BA727$850,000$1,169+3.0%
Aug 21, 201517CD3 BR · 3 BA2,260$4,995,000$2,210
Aug 14, 201517G2 BR1,385$1,975,000$1,426
Feb 10, 20157D/7E3 BR$2,795,000
Jan 30, 20157D1 BR727$2,681,250$3,688
Dec 15, 20142D1 BR870$1,087,500$1,250-16.3%
Oct 8, 20148B2 BR1,300$1,895,000$1,458-2.8%
Oct 7, 201431C2,143$6,700,000$3,126
Sep 11, 201415F2 BR1,388$1,350,000$973
Sep 9, 201431D6 BR3,872$6,700,000$1,730-16.2%
Jul 29, 201415E727$920,000$1,265
Jan 22, 20142HJ4 BR2,250$3,350,000$1,489-6.8%
Jun 26, 20137E1 BR · 1 BA729$750,000$1,029-3.8%
Mar 28, 201321E1 BR$750,000
Dec 14, 201226C1,312$3,995,000$3,045
Dec 7, 20124A1 BR783$690,000$881-1.3%
Nov 13, 201226F1,388$1,100,000$793
Oct 18, 201216CD3 BR2,275$3,700,000$1,626-5.1%
Sep 25, 20129D1 BR875$999,000$1,142+0.9%
Jul 23, 20123F3 BR2,100$2,875,000$1,369-7.3%
May 17, 201218C2 BR1,310$2,000,000$1,527-7.0%
May 7, 20123A1 BRnon-market transfer (excluded from $/sf & trends)783$670,000
Apr 30, 20127C2 BR1,310$1,575,000$1,202-4.5%
Apr 30, 20126CD3 BR2,257$3,200,000$1,418-3.0%
Apr 4, 201224F/G4 BR2,850$5,150,000$1,807-4.6%
Mar 14, 201215D1 BR870$1,010,000$1,161
Jun 28, 201121C2 BR1,310$2,400,180$1,832+10.4%
Jun 2, 201112B1,312$3,715,000$2,832
Jun 1, 20114J1 BR1,137$1,027,000$903-9.7%
May 4, 201124D1 BR870$1,065,000$1,224-9.4%
Apr 7, 201110A3 BR1,850$2,550,000$1,378
Mar 31, 201122A/22G4 BR3,200$4,875,000$1,523-1.5%
Mar 29, 201122Gnon-market transfer (excluded from $/sf & trends)1,383$625,000
Mar 29, 201122A3 BR2,550$4,250,000$1,667
Mar 23, 201122BC4 BR · 3 BA2,612$4,900,000$1,876+3.2%
Jan 12, 20117A3 BR1,822$2,550,000$1,400-1.7%
Jul 2, 201017G2 BR1,383$1,975,000$1,428
May 27, 201011G2 BR1,365$1,750,000$1,282-2.5%
Feb 23, 20104G1 BR1,050$965,000$919-8.1%
Dec 15, 20093J1,131$995,000$880
Aug 13, 200928ABC5 BR4,600$7,000,000$1,522-28.6%
Aug 13, 200928A/B$7,000,000
May 29, 200917E1 BR737$642,500$872-7.6%
Oct 27, 200821F2 BR1,388$2,040,000$1,470-5.8%
Oct 22, 20088F2 BR1,400$1,530,000$1,093-4.1%
Jul 15, 20084E2 BR1,032$1,550,000$1,502
May 12, 200810A3 BR1,850$2,550,000$1,378-3.8%
Apr 24, 200830D1 BR875$700,000$800
Apr 23, 200829B1,300$1,200,000$923
Jan 17, 200817B2 BR1,300$1,975,000$1,519-1.3%
Nov 30, 200729D1 BR870$1,080,000$1,241-9.6%
Oct 10, 2007B1,259$1,300,000$1,033
Aug 15, 20077D1 BR870$920,000$1,057-3.2%
Jun 29, 200715A3 BR$2,300,000
May 25, 20073D1 BR · 1 BA871$950,000$1,091
May 8, 200720E727$765,000$1,052
Apr 23, 20073M573$615,000$1,073
Mar 19, 20077C2 BR1,310$1,173,000$895-1.8%
Mar 16, 20075A1,830$1,966,000$1,074
Oct 10, 20062B1,052$2,420,000$2,300
Sep 29, 200612E727$732,500$1,008
Sep 27, 20063C1,052$2,610,000$2,481
Aug 10, 200621F2 BR1,388$1,585,000$1,142-0.6%
Aug 7, 200611F2 BR1,388$1,487,500$1,072-6.7%
Aug 7, 200623F2 BR1,388$1,920,000$1,383-2.8%
Jul 26, 200614E727$720,000$990
Jul 17, 20065G2 BR1,380$1,900,000$1,377-3.1%
Jul 14, 200611B2 BR1,350$1,595,000$1,181
Jun 20, 200622F1,388$3,025,000$2,179
Jun 8, 20064E2 BR1,100$1,134,250$1,031-3.5%
Apr 13, 200617C/D3 BR2,300$2,300,000$1,000
Feb 13, 20065C1,312$1,250,000$953
Jan 30, 200615D1 BR850$965,000$1,135-1.0%
Jan 26, 200613A3 BR1,822$2,100,000$1,153
Oct 26, 200532C3 BR2,143$3,150,000$1,470
Sep 30, 2005D3,045$3,600,000$1,182
Aug 23, 200525C940$1,265,000$1,346
Aug 17, 200517CD3 BR2,260$3,295,000$1,458
Aug 2, 200528F2 BR1,388$1,525,000$1,099
Jun 30, 20053F/G953$2,225,000$2,335
Jun 13, 200527F727$2,500,000$3,439
Jun 7, 20056D1,312$2,475,000$1,886
Jun 6, 200517G2 BR1,383$1,488,000$1,076
Jun 1, 200529G2 BR1,383$1,500,000$1,085-1.6%
May 16, 200517D870$3,200,000$3,678
May 11, 20054E2 BR1,032$1,100,000$1,066
Apr 21, 200512F1,383$3,075,000$2,223
Apr 20, 20058B2 BR1,300$1,100,000$846
Mar 28, 200530B2 BR · 2 BA1,300$1,775,000$1,365
Jan 24, 20054K806$750,000$931
Dec 23, 20048A3 BR · 3 BA1,822$1,575,000$864
Dec 13, 20044H2 BR1,400$1,250,000$893
Dec 10, 200420A3 BR$2,650,000
Nov 18, 20049B2 BR1,300$1,235,000$950-1.2%
Nov 8, 200414B1,300$1,225,000$942
Nov 2, 200426G1 BR · 1 BA1,383$900,000$651
Jul 13, 200415C1,312$999,000$761
May 27, 200415A3 BR$1,895,000
Jan 8, 20043K1 BR · 1 BA900$560,000$622
Nov 7, 200328C2 BR1,313$1,550,000$1,181
Nov 6, 200310A3 BR1,850$1,495,000$808
Nov 5, 200317F2 BR1,388$995,000$717

Sales sourced from NYC Department of Finance recorded transfers (BBL 1-01505-7502) and verified listing data. Apartment-level facts (line, condition, asking-price context) curated and cross-verified by The Roebling Team research desk. Not all transactions cross-verify with ACRIS records — sponsor and LLC purchases sometimes record at stipulated values rather than market price; square footage from recorded condo declarations and offering plans. Storage, parking, and commercial units are excluded from all figures. Floor- and line-level $/sf are time-controlled (each sale measured against the building’s going rate at the time of sale) and expressed at today’s pricing, so they isolate the floor or line premium rather than blend two decades of market movement.

Buying or selling at Carnegie Hill Tower?

Put this data to work.

Buying here

Know what’s fair before you offer — we’ll show you where each line trades, the building’s discount-to-ask pattern, and where the value sits right now.

Selling here

Price to the building’s real trajectory, not a guess — we’ll position your line against its true comps to maximize the outcome.

Schedule a consultation →
Corey Cohen, Principal · The Roebling Team at Compass
646.939.7375 · c.cohen@compass.com