The 97% Discount
The Roebling Report · By Corey Cohen · Principal, The Roebling Team at Compass
A 29-unit rent-stabilized East Harlem building worth millions in 2016 just sold for 97% less. The HSTPA 2019 destroyed the math on stabilized multifamily.
Picture this: a 29-unit rent-stabilized building in East Harlem, worth millions in 2016, just sold for 97% less. Yup, you read that right.
Why? The 2019 Housing Stability and Tenant Protection Act (HSTPA) flipped the script — capped rent hikes, eliminated deregulation, and reduced landlord cash flow. Rent-stabilized landlords — different from their free-market counterparts — can't keep up with 8% tax jumps or soaring insurance costs, so this building turned into a fire sale.
It's a win for tenant affordability — think a two-bedroom for $800 per month in Brooklyn Heights — but a brutal hit for recent buyers who didn't see the new regulations coming.
Where's the money moving?
Currently, investors are dodging rent-stabilized headaches. These buildings were once 43% of multifamily sales dollar volume in a single quarter; now they're down to 18%. Cash is flowing to free-market plays like Williamsburg condos and Long Island City rentals. Prices in this space? Still climbing, with median one-bedroom pricing at a high of $4,500 per month in Manhattan.
The split is real — rent-stabilized units lock in affordability but the rest of the market is a pressure cooker.
What's next?
While the 97% off sale is an anomaly, it's also a symptom. Rent stabilization has noble goals (an affordable NYC), but it's squeezing landlords — many of the mom-and-pop variety — and spiking free-market rents.
Maverick Real Estate Partners says values of rent-stabilized apartments are down 34% on average since 2019, and outliers like 312 East 106th Street prove it can get worse. Meanwhile, the price of non-regulated apartments rose 23%.
The 2023 Housing and Vacancy Survey counted 26,310 rent-stabilized apartments vacant but not available for rent, down from 42,860 in 2021, according to the NYC Comptroller's analysis. That category covers several reasons — units held for occasional use, awaiting or undergoing renovation, or in legal dispute — and does not by itself show how many owners held apartments off the market because renovation does not pay; the Comptroller estimated fewer than 2,000 low-rent stabilized units were vacant because of the cost of repairs. Rules that make renovation feasible could return some of these units to the market and ease pricing pressure on apartments across the city.
Thoughts on this? I'm always available for your real estate questions along with updated valuations that track the market.
Corey Cohen · Principal, The Roebling Team at Compass