- Year built
- 1891
- Type
- Condominium
- Floors
- 12
- Landmark
- In a historic district
Own an apartment here? See what it would sell for.
A Private Pricing Opinion — what your apartment at 5 East 16th Street would likely sell for today, what it costs to sell, and what you’d walk away with — reviewed personally against condition, exposures, renovation quality, and the competition actually on the market.
Eight homes, one per floor, at roughly 3,600 to 5,300 square feet each, half a block from Union Square. 5 East 16th Street offers some of the largest single-floor lofts in the Ladies' Mile district, in a building with a documented architect and a full LPC entry.
Alfred Zucker designed it in 1891 for Mary M. Leddy as an eight-story store-and-loft building, completed early in 1892 on the site of two five-story stone-faced rowhouses. Historical accounts record that it was briefly called the Geraldine and was built on Guastavino arches, a floor system suited to the printing presses of its first tenants: publishers including The Illustrated American, the United States Book Company and later Frederick A. Stokes Company. By 1904 garment makers were taking the floors. In 1909 Carrie M. Butler had Israels & Harder remove the parapet and add four stories. The upper floors were also connected to 85 Fifth Avenue; historical accounts record that the connection was later closed.
Photographers and studios followed in the 1970s, and the city's records show residential occupancy on the upper floors through the 1990s. A 1999 filing sought an amended certificate of occupancy for a change of use; a 2007 filing changed the fifth floor from commercial to residential. Filings since then recite eight dwelling units.
Architecture and unit composition
The LPC report describes a 50-foot front with a two-story base of rusticated red sandstone end bays. Round-arched entrances at each end, with clustered colonnettes and compound arches, recall English Norman doorways. Above the base, buff brick pilasters and terra-cotta spandrels frame the third through eighth floors, with double-height cast-iron colonnettes in the center bays. Floors nine through twelve are the 1909 addition. They repeat the window pattern without the rustication or terra cotta, so the addition reads clearly from the street. The twelfth-floor cornice has been removed.
Listing records describe full-floor lofts of about 3,600 to 5,300 square feet with three to five bedrooms and nine rooms in the largest configuration. The building backs onto the open lot at 6–12 East 17th Street, which gives the rear elevation light that most mid-block loft buildings on these blocks lack. The ground floor is a separately owned retail unit, and other lower floors are in commercial or office use.
Building operations
DOB filings record façade and masonry work in 2007 (selective terra-cotta pointing, brownstone restoration and brick repair) and a 2012 building alteration that required a heavy-duty sidewalk shed, pipe scaffold and hoist. In a building with eight homes and several commercial units, capital costs are allocated under the declaration across all units. Ask the managing agent for the allocation, the reserve balance and the most recent façade inspection.
Listing records from 2022–2025 put the monthly total for a 4,000- to 5,300-square-foot floor, common charges plus real estate taxes, at roughly $4,700–$5,800. Staffing is not documented in the records reviewed.
Classification
Department of Finance. The assessment roll classes unit 7, a residential floor in DOB and listing records, as an office condominium unit (RB) in tax class 4, recording its area as office space. PLUTO's billing-lot summary shows the whole condominium as commercial with no residential units. Class 4 assessment rules differ from those for residential condominium units, so model taxes from the specific unit's bill.
Department of Buildings. DOB filings record the apartment floors as residential, with eight dwelling units in filings from 2007 through 2012. A filing references certificate of occupancy no. 113788. Filings from 2019 cover an office renovation elsewhere in the building, consistent with mixed use.
What a buyer should do. Obtain the current certificate of occupancy and confirm it covers residential use of the specific floor. Confirm early that your lender will finance a unit the Department of Finance classes as office. The zoning (C6-2A, residential FAR 6.02 per PLUTO) permits residential use, so the question is how each unit is classified, not whether housing is allowed on the lot.
Recent sales
The retrade record
Lines that have traded more than once in the public record — the building’s appreciation arc, apartment by apartment.
Recent closings at this building, sourced from NYC Department of Finance records. Apartment-level detail (line, condition, asking-price context) verified upon consultation request.
| Date | Unit | Price |
|---|---|---|
| Jun 12, 2026 | 6 | $1,800,000 |
| Nov 8, 2024 | 1 | $4,500,000 |
| Nov 16, 2023 | 7 | $4,999,999 |
| Feb 21, 2023 | 8 | $6,200,000 |
| Nov 16, 2022 | 4 | $4,700,000 |
| May 18, 2021 | 9 | $5,800,000 |
Full closing history with price-per-square-foot over time, the complete retrade record, and every line that has traded.
Sales sourced from NYC Department of Finance recorded transfers (BBL 1-00844-7501; each condominium apartment is its own tax lot). Apartment-level facts (line, condition, asking-price context) curated and cross-verified in The Roebling Research Library. Not all transactions cross-verify with ACRIS records — sponsor and LLC purchases sometimes record at stipulated values rather than market price.
What would your apartment rent for?
Enter your apartment and I'll send you what it would rent for, from comparable closed leases at 5 East 16th Street and nearby.
Buying here? Condo closing costs with a mortgage typically run 3 to 6% of the price. See NYC co-op and condo closing costs, line by line.
Keep up with 5 East 16th Street and its market
The Roebling Report, monthly: Manhattan sales data and analysis, including buildings like 5 East 16th Street.
We’ll use your email for The Roebling Report and note your interest in this building. See our privacy policy.
What to know if you’re buying
Settle the classification before contract. Get the certificate of occupancy, the 1999 and 2007 change-of-use filings and your lender's sign-off on a unit the Department of Finance classes as office.
Read the commercial side of the budget. Commercial and office units share the building's costs. Their share of common charges, and any arrears, matter more here than in an all-residential condominium.
Landmark rules apply to the front. Window and exterior work generally needs LPC approval. Budget time for it.
What to know if you’re selling
The size is the product. A full floor of roughly 4,000 square feet or more, half a block from Union Square, in a building with a documented 1890s architect. Lead with the plan and the light.
Answer the classification question up front. A file with the certificate of occupancy and the DOB history saves weeks of buyer diligence.
Comparable buildings
If you're considering 5 East 16th Street, also evaluate:
- 15 Union Square West — loft-building conversion at the end of the block, with full-service amenities
- 15 West 17th Street — ten full-floor lofts in a Ladies' Mile building one block north
- 7 East 17th Street — commercial-loft condominium conversion on the next block north
- 17 East 17th Street — loft conversion on the same Fifth Avenue to Union Square stretch
- 105 East 16th Street — 1914 loft with cooperative residences inside a mixed-use condominium, east of Union Square
- 12 West 18th Street — 1885 Ladies' Mile loft condominium with residential and non-residential units
- 7 East 20th Street — 1907–08 loft condominium in the same district
More Flatiron buildings
- 4 West 16th Street — co-op
- 4W21, 4 West 21st Street — 2005 condop
- Madison Green (5 East 22nd Street) — 1985 condominium by Philip Birnbaum & Associates
- 7 East 17th Street — condominium
- 7 East 20th Street — 1907 condominium
- 7 West 14th Street — 1964 co-op
The neighborhood
For the full corridor — architecture, transit, and pricing across Flatiron — read The Roebling Team Guide to Flatiron.
How to read the facts on this page. Items attributed to an offering plan describe the building as it was offered at that filing — unit mix, square footage, the amenity program as planned. They are not a statement about how the building operates today. Tax and compliance figures are sourced separately to current City records and carry their own dates. House rules, staffing and fee policy can change by board resolution without any public filing: treat every policy line here as a starting point for diligence and confirm it with the managing agent. Where this page compares one building or neighborhood to another, that is our analysis of the recorded record — it names the measure, the period and the sample it rests on, and it is an observation about medians rather than a prediction about any particular apartment.
Considering a move at 5 East 16th Street?
Request a private building brief with the relevant comparable sales, current and off-market availability, and an apartment-specific view of value.
646.939.7375 · c.cohen@compass.com