Skip to content
Manhattan condos · below 96th $1,623/sf ▴3%Manhattan co-ops · below 96th $272K/room ▴4%Central Park perimeterPark Ave $452K/room ▴3%CPW $484K/roomFifth Ave $550K/roomBillionaires' Row $3,350/sfTribeca $1,928/sf ▴1%
Full index →
Cooperative · 1857
458-460 West 23rd Street
458 and 460 West 23rd Street, New York, NY 10011
Buildings·Chelsea·Cooperative

458-460 West 23rd Street

458 and 460 West 23rd Street, New York, NY 10011

BBL 1007200076 · BIN 1012715

CorridorChelsea
At a glance
Year built
1857
Type
Cooperative
Floors
5
Landmark
No
Pets
Written consent required. House Rule 14: no animal may be kept unless permitted in writing by the corporation, and that permission is revocable. Dogs must be carried or leashed in the public parts of the building. A weight, breed or number limit was not found
Own an apartment at 458-460 West 23rd Street?
Enter your apartment to see its recorded sale history and today’s estimate.
Considering a sale?

Own an apartment here? See what it would sell for.

A Private Pricing Opinion — what your apartment at 458-460 West 23rd Street would likely sell for today, what it costs to sell, and what you’d walk away with — reviewed personally against condition, exposures, renovation quality, and the competition actually on the market.

As seen inThe Wall Street Journal★ 92 reviews on Google

This is a two-house cooperative: 21 or 22 apartments across two 1857 brownstones on one block of Chelsea's landmarked 23rd Street frontage. Most walk-up cooperatives in the district sit in a single house with four to ten apartments. A corporation of this size spreads fixed costs and capital projects across more shareholders than its neighbors do.

The houses come from a row of nine identical buildings, Nos. 454 through 470, which Morgan Pindar completed in 1857. The LPC records that Pindar was forced to sell his property in 1858 to satisfy his creditors. The designation report's description of Nos. 458 and 460 is the least intact in the row: stucco over the basements, stoops gone, windows shortened, cornices damaged. Nos. 462 and 464 retain the most original detail. Exterior work on both fronts is subject to LPC review in the Extension.

The corporation's statements on file show it owning the land and both buildings, which points to fee ownership rather than a ground lease. They are audited and carry a reserve fund and an underlying mortgage. They are more than three years old, so we do not publish their figures. Request the current audited statements, the underlying mortgage's balance, rate and maturity, the reserve balance, the capital plan and any open assessment before you offer. See the buying section below.

Architecture and unit composition

Each house is 22 feet wide and about 54 feet deep on a 98.75-foot lot, with a rear yard behind it. Recorded apartment designations include numbered floors with letters (1B, 3A, 4A), basement-level units (BR, GRGF) and combined apartments (3B/4B). A 2022 DOB job combined two basement-level apartments at No. 458, and a 2024 DOB job covers a kitchen and bathroom renovation, with rebuilt non-load-bearing partitions, of a second-floor apartment at No. 460. Floor plans, ceiling heights and exposures vary by apartment. Request them from the managing agent for any apartment you consider.

Zoning is R7B. PLUTO records a built floor-area ratio of 2.82 on lot 76 against 3.00 allowed; that figure alone does not establish unused development rights, and development on a landmarked lot is subject to LPC review.

Building operations

The documents on file show a corporation that reports through a managing agent, with a purchase application handled by that agent's office. Management changed in 2020. Heat, hot water, laundry, storage and package arrangements are not described in the documents reviewed.

The house rules on file are the standard form in the offering plan's exhibit. They refer to incinerators, garages, elevators and a doctor's-office waiting room, none of which this building is shown to have, so read them as a baseline and ask for the rules currently in force. Terms that apply here:

  • Pets only with written consent, revocable (Rule 14).
  • Quiet hours for instruments and audio devices, 11:00 p.m. to 8:00 a.m. (Rule 5).
  • Floors in each apartment must carry rugs or equivalent noise-reducing material over at least 80 percent of each room, excluding kitchens, pantries, bathrooms, closets and foyers, unless the board waives it (Rule 19).
  • Window air-conditioning units and awnings need approval (Rule 7).
  • Any consent under the rules is revocable (Rule 23), and the board may amend the rules by resolution (Rule 28).

Policy framework

Documented in the file: the purchase-application package. It lists 26 items. They include two years of federal returns, bank-balance letters, a landlord reference, an employer or CPA letter, a business reference, two personal references, an appraisal, a signed house-rules acknowledgement and a move-in procedures form. If financing, add a loan commitment letter and three original recognition agreements. The fees listed are $600 for application processing, $125 per applicant for the credit check and a $1,000 refundable move-in deposit payable to the corporation. The cooperative will not waive its right of first refusal until all maintenance and assessments are current. The package is undated and may have been replaced. Ask for the current one.

Not established: the flip tax, financing ceiling, minimum down payment, post-closing liquidity, pied-à-terre, sublet terms and any pet limit beyond the consent rule. The corporation's 2019 and 2020 statements record sublet fee income, which indicates subletting has occurred; it does not state the rule. Treat every unlisted item as unknown, not as permitted or prohibited. Our co-op flip tax guide explains who usually pays and how it is calculated.

Recent sales

Apartments transfer as share transfers (ACRIS property type SP). Pricing follows the individual apartment — floor, whether it is a combined unit, condition and exposure — more than any building average. The competing set is the other walk-up cooperatives and small condominiums inside the Chelsea historic districts, several of them on this same tax block. It is not the elevator buildings nearby, and buyers who need an elevator or a doorman will screen the building out early. Co-op sales are valued per room rather than per square foot. Unit-level transaction history is maintained in The Roebling Research Library and shared with clients during diligence.

The retrade record

Lines that have traded more than once in the public record — the building’s appreciation arc, apartment by apartment.

BR+32%
$550,000 2019 → $728,000 2022
3B4B+27%
$1,457,000 2016 → $1,600,000 2019 → $1,845,000 2022
3A+14%
$590,000 2006 → $575,000 2011 → $620,000 2013 → $675,000 2021
GRGF-2%
$1,703,000 2014 → $1,675,000 2022
4A-8%
$1,525,000 2016 → $1,400,000 2023

Recent transfers at this building, sourced from NYC Department of Finance records. Apartment-level detail (line, condition, asking-price context) verified upon consultation request.

DateUnitPrice
Feb 12, 20251B$650,000
Aug 9, 20234A$1,400,000
Dec 13, 2022BR$728,000
Feb 6, 2023GRGF$1,675,000
Jun 15, 20223B4B$1,845,000
Dec 30, 20213A$675,000

Sales sourced from NYC Department of Finance recorded transfers (BBL 1-00720-0076). Apartment-level facts (line, condition, asking-price context) curated and cross-verified in The Roebling Research Library. Not all transactions cross-verify with ACRIS records — sponsor and LLC purchases sometimes record at stipulated values rather than market price.

For owners

What would your apartment rent for?

Enter your apartment and I'll send you what it would rent for, from comparable closed leases at 458-460 West 23rd Street and nearby.

Buying here? Co-op closing costs typically run 2 to 3% of the price. See NYC co-op and condo closing costs, line by line.

The Roebling Report

Keep up with 458-460 West 23rd Street and its market

The Roebling Report, monthly: Manhattan sales data and analysis, including buildings like 458-460 West 23rd Street.

We’ll use your email for The Roebling Report and note your interest in this building. See our privacy policy.

What to know if you’re buying

Get the current financials before anything else. The statements on file are for 2019 and 2020. Ask for the latest audited statements, the underlying mortgage's balance, rate and maturity date, the reserve balance, the capital plan and any assessment, open or proposed. Ask whether a reserve study has been done. The 2020 statements said none had been.

Confirm the unit count and your share allocation. Public records disagree: 21, 22 or 19. Maintenance is allocated by shares, so the schedule matters more than the count.

Price the facade. Both houses sit in the Extension, and the 1981 report records damaged cornices and altered fronts at these two addresses. Ask what facade, cornice and window work has been completed and what is planned, and budget LPC review time for any exterior change.

Run the carry on the whole building. Real estate taxes are passed through in maintenance. Use the True Monthly Carrying Cost Calculator with the actual maintenance figure, and confirm any co-op tax abatement is being passed to your apartment.

Prepare the board package early. Check your numbers against the Co-op Board Qualification Calculator before you submit. Get the financing ceiling and post-closing liquidity requirement in writing first.

What to know if you’re selling

Put the current statements in the buyer's attorney's hands early. Buyers will ask for the audited statements, the mortgage terms and the capital plan. Supply them with the listing.

Resolve the flip tax before you calculate proceeds. Get the rate, the base and who pays in writing, then run the numbers in the Seller Closing Cost Calculator.

Position against the right set. Walk-up row-house cooperatives and small condominiums in the Chelsea historic districts, not Chelsea generally.

Comparable buildings

If you're considering 458-460 West 23rd Street, also evaluate:

More Chelsea buildings

The neighborhood

For the full corridor — architecture, transit, and pricing across Chelsea — read The Roebling Team Guide to Chelsea.

Preparing a board package for this building?

The full playbook — what goes in the package, how boards read your financials, the interview, and the timeline — plus sample cover, reference, and personal letters you can adapt.

How to read the facts on this page. Items attributed to an offering plan describe the building as it was offered at that filing — unit mix, square footage, the amenity program as planned. They are not a statement about how the building operates today. Tax and compliance figures are sourced separately to current City records and carry their own dates. House rules, staffing and fee policy can change by board resolution without any public filing: treat every policy line here as a starting point for diligence and confirm it with the managing agent. Where this page compares one building or neighborhood to another, that is our analysis of the recorded record — it names the measure, the period and the sample it rests on, and it is an observation about medians rather than a prediction about any particular apartment.

Considering a move at 458-460 West 23rd Street?

Request a private building brief with the relevant comparable sales, current and off-market availability, and an apartment-specific view of value.

Prefer to speak directly? Schedule a consultation →
Corey Cohen, Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker · The Roebling Team at Compass
646.939.7375 · c.cohen@compass.com