Skip to content
Manhattan condos · below 96th $1,623/sf ▴3%Manhattan co-ops · below 96th $272K/room ▴4%Central Park perimeterPark Ave $452K/room ▴3%CPW $484K/roomFifth Ave $550K/roomBillionaires' Row $3,350/sfTribeca $1,928/sf ▴1%
Full index →

Bay Street

Bay Street holds 56 parcels along Sag Harbor's waterfront: houses, marinas and yacht clubs in the East Hampton portion of the Village.

Bay Street holds 56 tax parcels along Sag Harbor's waterfront, in the East Hampton portion of the Village. The 2025 roll lists 33 houses; the rest are marina, commercial, recreation and religious parcels. The median lot is under half an acre. This is the Village's working waterfront, with houses facing it.

Marinas and clubs

The Bay Street marina complex, including Sag Harbor Yacht Club and Breakwater Yacht Club near the foot of Main Street, sits on this street. For a house buyer that cuts both ways. The harbor views, the boating and the walk to Main Street are the reason to be here. Summer traffic, parking demand and activity on the commercial parcels are the cost. A house's position relative to the marinas moves its price.

Historic district

The 1994 boundary increase of the Sag Harbor Village District runs along Bay Street. A house inside the National Register or the Village's local district needs Village review for exterior changes and demolition.

Flood placement

Among residential and vacant parcels, 27 map to FEMA's minimal-hazard X zone, 6 to the 0.2 percent annual-chance area and 2 to AE, by parcel center point. The marina parcels on the water side are not in those counts.

Questions to settle before contract

  • What is directly across and next door: a marina, a club, a restaurant or a house?
  • Is the house inside the historic district?
  • Which flood zone applies at the house footprint?
  • Where does parking come from, and what does the Village allow on the lot?

Nearby

Division Street, Glover Street and Palmer Terrace are Sag Harbor's other streets on this site. The Sag Harbor guide covers the Village.

Considering Bay Street?

Request a private pricing review for a specific Bay Street property from The Roebling Research Desk, built around harbor position, neighboring uses, historic status and the comparables that compete.

Recorded sales

Recorded sales through July 2026

13 recorded arm’s-length sales of 12 distinct properties since October 2016 (13 house).

Houses sold 2023–2025: 5 single-parcel sales, from $2.63M to $11.3M. Too few for a median; the sales are listed below.

Historical transaction median, Apr 6, 2017 to Jan 6, 2026: $3,310,000 (13 single-parcel house sales). A decade-wide figure, not a current value.

Sale dateAddressTypeRecorded priceBeds (roll)Built (roll)Flood zone
Jan 6, 2026166 Bay StreetHouse$4,700,000——X
Dec 15, 2025100 Bay StreetHouse$11,250,000——X
Aug 14, 20254 Bay StreetHouse$3,894,000———
May 28, 202592 Bay StreetHouse$3,695,000——X
May 9, 2025167 Bay StreetHouse$2,632,842——X (0.2%)
Apr 24, 2023127 Bay StreetHouse$3,800,000——X
Oct 7, 2020163 Bay StreetHouse$2,730,000——X
Sep 2, 2020119 Bay StreetHouse$3,310,000——X
Jan 3, 2019146 Bay StreetHouse$1,965,000——X
Jun 28, 2018162 Bay StreetHouse$2,200,000——X (0.2%)
Apr 3, 2018119 Bay StreetHouse$2,975,000——X
Mar 15, 2018173 Bay StreetHouse$4,350,000——X (0.2%)
Apr 6, 2017169 Bay StreetHouse$1,300,000——X

Sale date is the date of sale on the transfer form. Beds and year built come from the assessment roll where it records them. Source: New York State real property transfer record (form RP-5217, filed with every deed), arm's-length sales as flagged by the state. These figures are a separate series from the Roebling Index, which is built from published market reports. How these tables are built.

Flood and coastal exposure

2 of 35 residential and vacant parcels sit in FEMA’s 1% annual-chance flood area (zones VE, AE, A or AO), where a mortgage from a federally regulated or insured lender requires flood insurance on the building.

FEMA zoneParcelsWhat it means for an owner
AE — 1% annual-chance flood, base flood elevation set2A 1% chance of flooding in any year (about 26% over a 30-year mortgage). Flood insurance is required with a federally backed mortgage. A new or substantially improved house must have its lowest floor at or above the base flood elevation shown on the map; local codes can require more.
X (shaded) — 0.2% annual-chance flood6A 0.2% annual chance of flooding (the “500-year” flood). Flood insurance is not federally required, but it is usually available at lower rates and a lender may still ask for it.
X — minimal flood hazard27Outside the mapped flood areas. Flood insurance is not federally required. Flooding can still happen from heavy rain and drainage.

Loans. In zones VE, AE, A and AO, any mortgage made, insured or bought by a federally regulated lender, Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, FHA or VA requires flood insurance on the building for the life of the loan. A lender can require it in zone X as well. A cash buyer is not required to insure.

Premiums. Since 2021 the National Flood Insurance Program prices each house on its own features (elevation, distance to water, cost to rebuild), so the zone is a starting point, not the price. Private flood policies are an alternative. An elevation certificate is the document every insurer asks for.

Renovating. In the 1% flood area, if work on a house costs half or more of the building’s market value, or a storm damages it that badly, the whole house must be brought up to current flood rules, which usually means raising it. Plan a renovation budget against that line.

Zone at each tax parcel’s center point; part of a parcel can sit in a different zone. Source: FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer (Suffolk County, map 36103C), retrieved 2026-11-12; flood insurance rate map panels effective Sep 25, 2009. A parcel-level determination needs the current map panel, any Letter of Map Revision or Amendment, and an elevation certificate. State coastal erosion hazard areas are mapped separately and are not shown here. Flood and coastal-erosion guide.

Own on Bay Street?

Request a pricing review of your property, prepared from the recorded sales on and around the road and what the public record shows about the parcel. Or ask about buying here.

Prefer to speak directly? Schedule a consultation →
Corey Cohen, Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker · The Roebling Team at Compass
646.939.7375 · c.cohen@compass.com

Considering a Hamptons purchase or sale?

A 30-minute consultation is the right starting point — the specific place, road or property you’re weighing, what the public record does and doesn’t settle, the diligence that matters on the South Fork, and connecting you with the right Compass East End specialist.

Corey Cohen
Corey Cohen
Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker · The Roebling Team at Compass
Schedule a consultation →
A note on representation

The Roebling Team at Compass is led by Corey Cohen, a New York licensed associate real estate broker. For the Hamptons we bring along a vetted Compass agent who specializes in the East End. This page and its calculators are research, not an offer of representation.